Suggested by OriginalA

Both of these mecha are making their debut on FactPile. The UEF Mongoose is from the Supreme Commander franchise, while the Spartan Destroid is from Robotech.

For my money, the only way the Mongoose could win is in a mid-range fight. The Spartan has the range advantage with the missile capacity, and in close combat, they are extremely flexible and fast.

Is there any chance for the Mongoose to win?

Here we have a match in where I am taking the complete fanboy route and pick the SDF-1 from Robotech to win while I wait for L-W’s reply to show me at least 13 ways in which the SSD is superior.

But take it easy on the old Admin, he’s celebrating his birthday!

Suggested by War Wizard

Making his first ever appearance on FactPile is Scott Bernard from the Robotech franchise. I know most people will hardly care about this match, but like I heard someone famous once say: “It’s good to be the king!”

Anyways, for this match, it takes place on Earth, Scott has a fully equipped cyclone with no issues of Protoculture to worry about.

Who wins this fight?

Suggested by War Wizard
Well, this is a very tough match to post. While Robotech is my clear favorite “anime” series, I don’t think there is much hope for the Shadow Fighter against one of the greatest Shogun Warriors. Mazinga (The West version) just has too much for the fighter to handle. Still, I think it would be a decent fight.

Who do you think would win?

For the sakes of this match, it does fall under the “Mecha” category, despite the fact that Megatron is an intelligent life form and the battloid is is piloted by a living creature. Regardless, I don’t see Megatron having much of a chance against the Invid. With it’s ranged weapons the Royal Command Battloid can attack from a safe distance inflicting damage to Megatron. Should it get to physical combat, I think the Transformer could win the fight.

What say you?

Suggested by Matapiojo
Well now, my all-time favorite sci-fi series in Robotech going against the powers of Star Trek. With all powers of all entities in play, Robotech couldn’t withstand whatever the Q Continuum wanted to do. However, should “Q” find the micronians interesting enough and let them battle un-impeded, Robotech would be able to take care of the Star Trek universe in time.

FANBOY ALERT: Robotech is my absolute all-time favorite sci-fi series…

…so I’m very biased as to who would win, so I’ll let you, dear reader, determine the outcome.

Who wins?

So, if you’re a Robotech fan, here’s an interesting question – Suppose Khyron never obliterated the SDF-1, SDF-2 and his ship?

Would the Robotech Masters still be as interested in acquiring the protoculture matrix? (I think so)
Would the SDF-3 even been built?
Where would Captain Gloval end up?
Would the Invid even learn about planet Earth?

Here we have two my of my favorite ‘toons from the 80’s (Yes, I’m that old) – and while the Transformers may have been more popular, Robotech would win this battle with little trouble.

While the Transformers may have Unicron, Robotech have the Invid, Robotech Masters, and most importantly, protoculture.

Robotech wins in a landslide!

No research needed here. Easily a battle of the ages. Take into consideration the captains of each ship and the advantage would go to the Enterprise. But for sheer firepower the Super Dimensional Fortress would make toast of the “Class of Starfleet” in about 12 seconds.

Enterprise

• Phasers
• Photon Torpedos
• Deflector shields
• Impulse engines
• Warp Drive

Super Dimensional Fortress (SDF-1)

• Super Dimension Energy cannon
• 4 1780 mm rail cannons
• 8 Beam Cannons
• Space-fold Drive
• Omni-directional barrier

My money is on the SDF-1 – any way the Enterprise survives?