Suggested by overlord

Here we have the Pillar of Autumn from Halo up against the SDF-1 from Robotech.

For this battle, the upgraded Pillar of Autumn is being used. Also, neither ship has taken any damage prior to the battle. Any fighters on board are fully armed and in standby.

The PoA also has an escort of 100 AV-14 Attack VTOL’s, 50 Dropship 77 Heavy-Troop Transport ships, 100 C709 Longsword-class Interceptors, 50 Sabre’s, 100 Open Frame 92′s, 50 F99 Unmanned Combat Vehicles, and 50 AC-220 Gunship’s.

While at first glance, it appears that the PoA will make an easy stomp (overlord’s comments, not mine, Admin), the battle will be long because note that the SDF’s vehicles double as mechs.

Despite what the Halo fans will trot out, the SDF-1 will absolutely destroy the PoA in little time. Even with all the mechs that can be set against the Super Dimensional Fortress, the UNSC is clearly outmatched in this fight. Since overlord took the time to list the load out for the Pillar of Autumn, here is what the SDF-1 carries:

Weapon Systems:

Main Reflex Cannon
4 Rail Guns
1 Large triple-barreled Laser Turret
8 Large Laser Turrets
12 Long Range Missile Turrets
48 Medium Range Missile Turrets
48 Dual Barreled 40cm Auto Cannons
48 Laser Cannons

Vehicle/Mecha Complement
36 Excalibers
24 Gladiators
72 Raidar-X’s
56 Spartans
24 M.A.C. II’s
200 VF-1A’s
50 VF-1J’s
40 VF-1S’s
12 VF-1D’s
6 Armoured Veritechs

Even if Master Chief was piloting, there is no way the PoA makes it out alive.

What say you?

Suggested by shaun182

An interesting match between two ships utilizing some similar technology in the shape of an artificial AI that becomes part of the ship.

I can’t say with authority on which ship has the edge, but is luck is a part of the equation…

Which ship would win?

Suggested by L-W
Interesting match here. For me, my choice comes down to which ship I would want to be on if I was a passenger on the ship. For my money, I would take the Enterprise for the win here.

What say you?

Suggested by Ryan
This battle looks like a fun match to watch. While the Battlecruiser appears to be more mobile, the Pillar of Autumn looks to have more firepower and could ultimately sway victory to it’s side.

Which ship wins?