You know it’s a major fight when each combatant only has one name, and no one will get confused as to who is being talked about.
I think the knee-jerk reaction is to give the victory to Superman – but would that be the ultimate outcome?
What say you?
Asger on Xena Vs Aragorn
Jwlynas on Xena Vs AragornAsger on Jack Krauser Vs RamboJwlynas on Na 'Vi Vs Helghast
Belisaurius on Na 'Vi Vs Helghast
walkingcorn on Na 'Vi Vs Helghast
orber on Jack Krauser Vs Rambo
AHEM on Na 'Vi Vs HelghastBelisaurius on Na 'Vi Vs HelghastAHEM on Sword of Truth Vs Alagaesia
SinZero on Na 'Vi Vs HelghastJwlynas on Na 'Vi Vs HelghastAHEM on Xena Vs AragornJwlynas on FactPile FlagAHEM on Cloud Vs Link Vs Kratos Vs Sauron Vs Thor Vs Richard Rahl Vs Ganondorf Vs Rand al'Thor
Loading ...
FactPile News Feed 
March 18, 2009
#1
I think that superman will destroy thor.
March 18, 2009
#2
(My post assumes Thor is not wielding the Odinforce)
Superman would deflect most of Thor’s attacks with his Kryptonian powers, then wrench Mjolnir from his hands (As seen in JLA/Avengers). With this great weapon, he’d blast Thor with his own attacks and finish him with a crackling strike of lightning. The big blue boyscout wins this one.
March 18, 2009
#3
Now with the Odinforce…
March 18, 2009
#4
“Now with the Odinforce…”
This isn’t a fight with the Odinforce. Thor just points at Supes and the Last Son is fried.
March 18, 2009
#5
“This isn’t a fight with the Odinforce.”
Oh.
My appologies.
It looks as though my issued computer by the United States Federal Government has a bug that specifically targets Factpile scenarios, rendering crucial information invisible. I will do everything within my power to get that sorted out as soon as humanly possible.
/SarcMash
March 18, 2009
#6
“It looks as though my issued computer by the United States Federal Government has a bug that specifically targets Factpile scenarios, rendering crucial information invisible. I will do everything within my power to get that sorted out as soon as humanly possible.”
It’s a statement of fact. Get over yourself. It would be a slaughter, not a conflict.
March 18, 2009
#7
@Mata.
It’s obvious Admin means classic Thor. Everyone already knows about the odinforce, it’s an overpowered fan service pat on the back to Thor fans who can’t stop whining about his relatively low power level in comparison to other gods.
This isn’t a wiki, so you have no reason to constantly list facts that anyone can look up within seconds.
“my issued computer by the United States Federal Government”
We get it, you work for the facist regime that everyone hates, shut up.
March 18, 2009
#8
“It’s obvious Admin means classic Thor.”
Really?
Please, do tell how you drew that conclusion from the few lines given above? Also, when did I list anything resembling a wiki fact here?
I’ll be kind to you and restrain myself from arguing back and forth on pointless issues that stray away from the fight. Please be open-minded enough to allow yourself the benefit of some constructive criticism.
Never start a debate with “My post assumes…” as your opening statement because in all honesty, you do not need to ASSUME anything when the point to discuss is OBVIOUS.
Let me remind you that it was YOU who brought up the Odinforce and whom established the “lets not use it here” argument.
March 18, 2009
#9
As much as I hate him, Superman would win this one.
March 18, 2009
#10
I think it would be pretty much a tie…but if it is in Metropolis or Asgard – anything in the surrounding area would be smashed to dust. I ran this fight through my mind a while back and I am glad it has come onto this site. I see Thor and Superman as near equals but Thor does have Mjonir capable of opening vortexes and commanding storms (primarily thunder and lightning). This is honestly the dream fight for a MArvel vs. DC scenario and I would like it to be explained well.
Before I give a detailed choice…I have to think for a while.
March 18, 2009
#11
so is this pre-crisis,current,or what?
March 18, 2009
#12
also,are we using OF,Rune,or classic?
March 18, 2009
#13
um no idea not this kind of nerd (not saying im not a nerd though)but ill put my money on the god of thunder
March 18, 2009
#14
I said let’s not use the odinforce because this is an even and interesting battle without it. With it, the battle too obviously goes to Thor.
Plus, for the sake of inclusion, shouldn’t we use incarnations of characters most well known by non-fans? That way we can have more people get in on the argument.
March 18, 2009
#15
Well, Superman’s powers are based on physics (albeit convenient COMICbook physics) and Thor’s power’s are… mystical at lease, Straight-Up Magic depending on your take on “the Gods” of Azeroth. Superman is vonrable to Magic, but I suppose the question is whether any of Thor’s Magic would harm Supes. If we assume that brute force and lightening aren’t going to do much to Kal-El, then perhaps not, but I think that if nothing else Thor could block the Sun and eventually wear Superman down…
Despite liking the character of Supes more, I would bet on Thor in the long run…
March 18, 2009
#16
Duh, I meant Asgard….
March 18, 2009
#17
In my opinion, i think Superman would win over Thor.
From what i know, Thor is able to lift up to 1/3 of the Earth’s weight, when not powered by “Warriors Madness”. Since i know that superman has the strength to move the ENTIRE planet, and even Hold Back Black holes, he outnumbers Thor’s Strength (though i do no know how strong Thor is i full power). In terms of Thor using the weather against superman, Mother Earth ( The ultimate control of weather) does not even phase superman one bit. I know supes is weak against magic, but i am not too sure that Thor uses magic. Also it depends on which superman we are talking about. I know the most recent Superman has the power close to hulks (i ve even heard he ties and/or beats hulk) so if the most recent supes goes against Thor, i think thor is sure to be done for.
If it is the supes from ( i think Modern Era) then it is hard to say but i still vote in favor of superman.
Again, i havent been following this for a while but is the most recent superman the one with the Ability to travel faster than light, and can move planets, or is it the superman that had his powers reduced?
March 18, 2009
#18
Odinforce is the deciding factor here, with it Thor can literally turn his opponents Sun loving cells against themselves, causing them the irreversibly and rapidly destabilize at a molecular level.
The Soviet Union attempted the same ploy in “The Dark Knight Returns” with an experimental nuke designed produce an almost specialized self-sustaining electromagnetic field, in the resultant aftermath of the detonation (Despite easily surviving the blast) Superman began to weaken and tire, until his entire body began to fall into total cellular degradation at an alarmingly high rate (He appeared as an Old dying Man within seconds). If it was not for the field of Flowers he had landed in, he would have most certainly have died there and then.
March 18, 2009
#19
current thor vs current superman…im leaning towards thor.
March 18, 2009
#20
thor will win in my book.
March 19, 2009
#21
Hmmm…I have to call it now i guess…: Superman. “Warrior Madness” is great but Hulk can hold that down with one hand. Our old pal Kal-El has moved planets and flown through suns at his top power level: not to mension kill the unkillable at the cost of his own life. Plus…during a Marvel vs. DC crossover comic Superman has been shown to be capable of wielding Mjinor – so a slip up on Thor’s part and he might get bashed a few times by his own super-powerful hammer.
Superman is not a stranger to being hit by lightning – Captain Marvel anyone? But magic in a pure form affects him like a normal human. But regardless – Superman wins.
March 19, 2009
#22
“current thor vs current superman…im leaning towards thor.”
I completely agree.
March 23, 2009
#23
“current thor vs current superman…im leaning towards thor.”
not if a kryponite is present
March 26, 2009
#24
“not if a kryponite is present”
Right, it would be easier…..
May 11, 2009
#25
i will go for thor he is very power full he is a god of thunder but super man is very powerfull but odin died and all his power came to thor
May 12, 2009
#26
So… why can’t the God of Thunder block out the sun? If teh Sun is blocked, Supes is boned.
May 14, 2009
#27
Ben 10 VS Superman
May 21, 2009
#28
Super Man will fly very quikly to Thor then start punching him thor will hit him with his hammer superman will fly. away thor will fly to him superman will punch thor will say by all power of odin destroy this person then thunder will come and superman will loos.
May 21, 2009
#29
Strength: tie
Invulnerability: tie
Speed: edge Superman
Power: Thor, no contest
Fighting Skills: Thor, HEAAVILY
Tactics: Thor
Durabilty: slight edge, Superman (depending on internal stored solar energy level)
Versatility: Thor
Strategy: Thor
Senses: Superman
One hit finisher capacity: Thor
Experience: Thor
Will Power: tie
Fighting spirit: Thor
Intelligence: Thor
Common sense: Superman
Paraphenilia: Thor
Sidekicks/associates: Thor “team” beats Supes “squad”
Team back up: JLA edge over Avengers
Overall Thor wins.
9/10
May 21, 2009
#30
*Correction…
Intelligence: tie
May 21, 2009
#31
Superman to thor – “Our universe goes up to eleven”
Word of God says Superman wins I’m afraid.
May 28, 2009
#32
You know Thor is more naturaly stronger than Super Man or The Hulk. Thor was born with his strength not altered by radiation. He is not only the god of thunder but of the earth as well due to his mother. Super Man is no genius of a fighter if he had to be tought by Batman and Wonderwoman. Thor has went through giants, demi gods, and eternals for thousands of years. Some say Super Man is stronger than Thor but Thor does have the warriors madness that amplifies his power 10x. Thor’s God blast would tear SM’s head off. I don’t see a great contest here if Thor opens up. Plus Thor is infintely more popular than Super Man every will be because we say Thor’s name every week in our daily lives and dedicate the whole day to him. Thursday.
June 17, 2009
#33
thor wins becuz his hammer is magic and superman`s weakness is magic
June 29, 2009
#34
Ok lets see. Superman vs Thor. Id give it to Superman because he is stronger and faster than Thor in most comics Ive read. The Hulk can beat Thor and has number of times and Superman can beat the Hulk he has a number of times. Not only that Superman beat Thor in JLA vs Avengers comic.
I see Thor putting up a good fight but I see Superman getting 2 to 3 punches in every 1 hit Thor can because Superman can move almost has fast as the flash and simply put Thor cant. In the end I see Thor tiring and Superman still going.
Now on to are Thors powers Magic? Thors hammer is magic yes but Superman is not weak against Magic I dont know where this came from? Superman can be affected by Magic just like any hero INCLUDING THOR. Wasnt he turned into a frog? Every being is affected by magic Simply put but it is not Supermans weakness. One shot from the hammer will not knock out Superman my reason for that is Captain Marvels powers are granted by Magic but then do not weaken Superman. Superman even beats Captain Marvel. So this issue does not apply in this fight it is just a really heavy ass hammer both can use it to knock the other out and Superman is fast enough to take it from Thor and use it against him before he can see it coming,
Next issue if you give Thor ODIN- FORCE then you must let Superman get his boost also. Superman PRime or Precriss Superman and if that happens Thor Odin force loses still.
Superman is the better man in this one.
July 2, 2009
#35
there is something very powerful u are forgeting….odinforce
it pretty much allows thor to point at supes and he will die
July 4, 2009
#36
no contest at all superman would kill thor have you not seen thor vs hulk thor gets brat near death
firstly superman is stronger than thor he moves planets whe at full strength
also hes way way faster
he ismore durible thor would die in a nuke blast supes would walk on oh and thor dosnt have a healing factor like superman
and superman can weild mjolnir
also superman already kicked thors ass
im my scenario if supes intended to kill thor he would just fly into thor hit hima few times to stun him then fly him to and throw him into the sun
magic or no magic thor would loose
July 7, 2009
#37
yes because thors ability(odin force) to kill any enemy he want would have no effect on the fight what so ever……..nice logic there thezzzzzzzz
if supes tries to throw him into the sun thor makes the sun dissapear
if supes tries to puch thor he makes his hands disapear
superman could only lift mjolnir for a short amount of time aswell
the hulk vs dvd isnt canon thor wins
July 9, 2009
#38
Wait…so it this classic or Odin-Force Thor. Because, with the OF, Thor wins. Classic Thor…hard to say. I am leaning towards Supes, not because of intellegence or fighting skill, but because of speed. Supes moving at FTL speeds would let him put a pounding on Thor before he could react (unless the Thunder God has FTL abilites and reflexes?). Such a good match overall. Still can’t really decide, but leaning slightly towards man of steel.
- pondering fool
July 9, 2009
#39
@pondering fool
it is usually the most recent version of the character so odin force counts here
July 10, 2009
#40
Thanks cyborg pirate ninja jesus. Well…ya, Loius Lane will be having a bad day when she finds out Clark Kent disappeared forever……
August 5, 2009
#41
You know it’s a major fight when each combatant only has one name, and no one will get confused as to who is being talked about.
I think the knee-jerk reaction is to give the victory to Superman – but would that be the ultimate outcome?
Lois Lane and Sif then drops off their clothe and fight over
August 21, 2009
#42
Without the Odinforce and with Supes boosted up on excess solar energy, then this should be a pretty even fight. I’d love to say that Superman would win, but I’m leaning towards Thor simply because of his divine nature.
With the Odinforce, though, Thor simply has too many advantages and too much raw power for Superman to keep up. Thor wins easily.
August 22, 2009
#43
Can we use Superman One Million? It is the same superman we all know and love, just set a couple thousand years in the future. He is pretty sick. Wonder what Thor would be in a couple thousand years…..
- pondering fool
August 24, 2009
#44
you know who has won the fight when you have to give one combatant “power ups” to make it even
thor has won because he has the odin force
thor for fp award?
August 28, 2009
#45
Odinforce is pretty sick. If Thor indeed has it in this fight, I give the fight to the Norse God. Factpile award for Thor.
- pondering fool
September 3, 2009
#46
2 votes for fp award
September 22, 2009
#47
I support the nomination for Thor.
November 12, 2009
#48
“I support the nomination for Thor.”
Mmmhh….so painful for me to go against my hero, but OF is looking pretty convincing……
- the pondering fool
December 28, 2009
#49
I’d say these two would be even in most categories, but as every strike from mighty Mjolinor would disrupt Supermans invulnerability I’d give the win to the Odinson.
4 votes for Thor.
February 17, 2010
#50
im revoting for thor….simply because…well he wins