While this certainly appears to have the makings of a classic fight, I’m not sure the StarCraft universe has the depth needed to keep up with the universe of Star Wars.
From the race selection alone, Star Wars has the advantage, same goes for vehicles.
Does the StarCraft universe have a fighting chance?





November 9, 2008
#1
Nothing I can think of could possibly beat Star Wars
November 10, 2008
#2
“Nothing I can think of could possibly beat Star Wars”
Go look at the Warhammer 40K vs Star Wars match…
However, this fight is indeed in favor to the big SW. SC is still very green. Simply unleashing the Jedi against the Terrans, and the Sith against the Protoss would tip things to SW. Then (like the Duel match) put the rest of the Empire’s resources against the Zerg and call it a day.
No need to even call down the rest of the SW universe to clean up this mess.
November 10, 2008
#3
Considering the canon information of Star Craft makes up a small spatial sector, a few systems at tops…..Complete domination by the Empire alone, like Mata said.
November 11, 2008
#4
well i said anything i could think of, and i didnt think of warhammer 40k lol
November 16, 2008
#5
LoL! easy! star wars guys has the all force powers and if death star would do the superlazer to the starcrafts planet, it will blow up!!
Go star wars, go!
December 4, 2008
#6
i just got here from emire vs zerg one thing makes starcraft win SCOURGES
take out a carrior massive ship with like 8 and with super reproduction… death star would be gone in like 800 scourges its only the size of a small moon OF AN INCREDIBLY SMALL PLANET!!!!! AND WITH THE QUEENS PARISITE MOVE also if this happened aniken would not be darth vader he would be the KING OF BLADES bringing the force to the zerg and judging by dark templares role in starcraft they would be force worshipers and the hole zealot army would be mini jedis (Not very good ones but an army…) the terans would be owned but zerg has scourges and just look at the protoss and they would have had to kick fenix out of the jedi councel you know im right
-think about it
December 4, 2008
#7
-aniken would have became king of the blades instead of darth vader (joking…or am i)
-the death star would be gone in like 800 scourges -it takes like 5 to take out a far more advanced shielded protoss fleet ship!!!!
-zealots would be like an army of padawan lurners!!!!!!
-LOOKING AT THE ROLE OF PROTOSS IN STARCRAFT templares would now the force (lightning storm, mind controle etc.)
- terrain would handle the sucky rebals and people like that
-the queens ability parisite would be taking jedis like hot cakes!!!!! and dont give me that hittened senses crap you saw those jedi killed in 3!!!!!!!!!!
-zergs abillity to infest would get them there own jedi (serah style infest)AND cammand center style infect)exploding storm troopers!!!!!!!!!!!
-the protoss have invisable jedi knights
-archons would be lie force gods of the dark and light sides
-much of starcrafts conflict was mineral wars star wars had a diffrent scource those huge armys!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-hon solo in his ship would be killed by jim raynor in his battle cruser!
-starwars is from the past starcraft is from the future so star craft has slightly better tach(I know low blow)
-the marine medic combo destroys the rebal wookie combo LOL
-zerg has super reproduction ON TOP OF ITS UNLIITTED RESOURSES i mentioned erlier
-im a huge fan of both of these franchises but the scourges…
thin on this for awhile before you say star wars…
December 27, 2008
#8
Wow spoa, you actually are serious, are you? You think Darth Vader would just stand there and get himself infected? He would sense them coming from miles away, and he would have back-up. Stormtroopers would outnumber all of the three Starcraft races on their own. And I’m not even talking about Clone Troopers, Mandelorians, battledroids and the Yuuzahn Vong yet.
Yuuzahn Vong would scorch the Zerg by the way.
Now, to counter all of your ‘facts’:
- I don’t know who ‘aniken’ is, but if you’re talking about Anakin, you are indeed joking.
- Scourges won’t even reach the Death Star. It is most likely protected by an entire Imperial starfleet, and thousands upon thousands of TIE-fighters. Not to mention that the Scourges would harmlessly explode upon contact with the Death Star’s shield, and let’s not forget that it has 20.000 turbolaser batteries. How you think only 800 Scourges would break through all that, is beyond me.
- You seriously think a Zealot could beat a Jedi?
- Some pathetic little psychic powers are nothing compared to the power of the Force.
- If the Rebels could beat the Empire, they could beat the Terran Dominion with ease. In fact, I think they have about the same military strength.
- The Jedi never expected to be fired upon by their own troops. They could handle a Queen with ease.
- Once again, you think a Jedi would be stupid enough to stand around and get infected? Game mechanics don’t work in the official canon, so you can forget exploding Stormtroopers.
- Sith Assassins (and Protoss aren’t comparable to Jedi Knights damnit!).
- Say hello to Darth Sion, Darth Nihilius, and Ulic Qel-Droma. And once again, Force > psychic powers.
- I really don’t understand what you just said…
- A battlecruiser wouldn’t even be able to hit the Millenium Falcon. And if we’re talking about Han Solo as an admiral: Star Destroyer >>>>>>>>>> Battlecruiser.
- Even though they are from the past, it’s a DIFFERENT GALAXY, and their tech is still far superior.
- Game mechanic, thus invalid.
- If the Zerg are so great, then why did they get beaten by a patheticly small colonial empire?
- Once again, Scourges would get annihilated.
I indeed thought about this for a while, and Star Wars still has this in the bag, sorry lad.
December 29, 2008
#9
i did not know we were talking all time periods!!!! thats not even fare!!!!!! starwars has so much history!!!!!!!!!!!!!! starcraft has the games and like 4 novels and i never said a zealot could kill a jedi! if its all time perids collided you are right there would be no fight but if were talking last episode of SW starcraft would win and what do you mean there would never be any inffected anything i wasnt talking master yoda jedis!!!!! I was talking padwan lurners yoda wouldput up a fight but he is dieing of age and nolonger has his saber or connection to the force… you looked to deep into what i was saying AND the zerg fought the war with the protoss for a melinea and still destroyed there sivilisation in the end AND zerg almost conquerd the galaxy i dont know were they will pick up in starcraft 2 and for you saying the zerg would not destroy the death star!!!! if 3 republican ships can take it out and 4 people a wookie and a bunch of carebares can take out the shields the deathstar would be gone in the first few waves
and you clearly havent played much starcraft if you think the zerg would go down so easy they can come back from vertuel extinction in days!!!!
once the death star shields were down the death star would be yamotoed by a fleet of battle cruisers
-(this is going way out there but thought id say it you dont have to take this seriusly) if the zantaboen was around starwars would be screwed
all and all this needs a littile more structure to be truely answered…
March 1, 2009
#10
well spoa u do not really understand the real power of the galactice empire, plus the might of rebels and other factions in the star wars universe. let me begin.
1º of all: u said zerg were about to take over the galaxy, u dont really understand do u, they only fought in the koprulu sector ONLY!, u starcraft fans always confuse this with the entire galaxy, damnit! actually the UED devastated the entire sector WITH ONLY AN EXPEDITION FLEET! with the entire might of the earth humans, koprulu sector wuold have been completely oblitarated, now compare earth with an entire galaxy, everyone united into a single flag (same with the small part of wat starcraft is compared with its galaxy)
2º Zerg: they arent that mighty as u may think! if u see the official information they dont even get past the 10 million zergs, they were like 12 broods in total, and now theyre commanders are dead (overmind and cerebrates), only infested terrans remain. damnit everyone always overestimate the zerg, THEY ARE NO THAT POWERFUL! everything has its weak point!
3º empire: people always think the empire sucks! this is totally untrue!, first, they fell u know why?, even though they were weakened with the death star destroyed, actually the empire still overpowered the rebels by a LOT! the reason why they fell its because the emperor died and the fragmented commanders fought eachother to take control of the empire, so thats because it is called the imperial remnant, thers still lots of imperials but fragmented. now lets think that emperor never died, and the rebels allied with the empire to destroy the invaders or to obliterate the starcraft SECTOR! (NOT GALAXY), as we all know each universe allied themselvs under the same flag.
and people allways say that the death star sucked balls, if the 2º one could be completed it was going to be invencible! NO SHIP (NO FUCKING SCOURGE) will ever! ever! destroy it, only a 3º death star could match it!,
4º armys: now lets begin, Starcraft: the zerg, exciled terrans, UED terrans, and protoss: zerg, with its climax might, theyre mightiest army was of 4 million zergs (garm brood) and all combined were 8.5 million zergs including infested terrans, thats actually not that much, but lets poing first that the zerg are completeley vulnerable to radiation, no zerg stands radiation (from larva to ultralisks), exciled terrans, dominion, kel-morian combine, umojan and raynors raiders, ja! zerg defeated them all with ease in many occasions, and the UED (only and EXPEDITIONARY TASK FORCE DAMNIT!) devastated the whole renegade terran, so we can point they suck, theyre climax was an army of 400 battlecruisers with theyre former fighter ships, and a 3 million armada, lets say plus some super soldiers clones yet no official (im even giving them some advantage), now UED, (wow theyre really tough!) theyre entire army its unknown but they control 12 solar systems so we can be sure that theyre are strong, but still doesnt compare with the empire alone! i cant say more because thers anything more, lets say 2 billion armada. and finally the protoss, well theyre tough but still not that strong, with only 4 systems under control, and several starcruisers, (lets point this, a carrier is shit compared to a star destroyer) theyre complete armada consits of 6 million protoss and a lot of cruisers, but thats it.
STARCRAFT POWERS, now lets see theyre special edges, well the very psionic protoss, creating storms, archons and a small part of terrans are psichyc as well, hmm… i dont think theres more, well kerrigan and dark templar, just variants of the originals, but thats it.
NOW lets point STAR WARS universe, lets begin with that the enitre galaxy is already populated and that every sector its known to everyone!
GUYS, THE WHOLE MIGHT OF THE EMPIRE OUTMATCHES ALMOST EVERY UNIVERSE KNOWN, WITH THE CONTROL OF 4.8 MILLION SYSTEMS!!! DAMN THATS POWERFUL!!!, (that in the movies only the most important zones and planets are showed doesnt mean that they dont have them or doesnt exist, HAVE THIS ON MIND!), complete with super technolgy, and trillions of cloned and conscripted soldiers they overpower everything!, and having several siths under its control, empire would overthrow stacraft with ease!!!!, and a sith would wreck havoc in any battle (rebels just were too afraid of fighting the battlefield if a single sith was present!!! unless a jedi was also present) now lets combine the WHOLE MIGHT OF EVERY SINGLE JEDI AND SITH AND FORCE HYBRIDS IN THE ENTIRE UNIVERSE!!! THEY ALONE COULD DO THE JOB!
actually calculating the whole land imperial armada is made up of 8 trillion soldiers plus machines and land airships AND droids. now the official number of imperial stardestroyers is 25 THOUSAND STARSHIPS!!!! PLUS STRONGER AND LESSER CRUISERS!!!! AND… AND!!! THE MILLIONS OF TIE FIGHTERS/BOMBERS/INTERECEPTORS AND MUCH MORE!!!! its just too overwhlming, if scourge is that overwhelming, well TIE fighters are clearly outnumbering them!!! now special features, entire industrial and militar worlds under imperial command!!! and not just worlds, solar systems!, several super star destroyers!!!! they were from 10 to 20 times the size of a star destroyer!!!
now see the size, a battlecruiser is just 300 meters long, a star destroyer is 1.6 miles long!!!!! and the executor star destroyer is 12 miles long!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! that is incomparable! and the eclypse super destroyer is 17.5 miles long!!!!!! DAMNIT!!!! HOW THE HELL STARCRAFT ITS GOING TO MATCH THAT MONSTROSITY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
backsotry, starcraft has just 2 games (3 soonly) and 4 novels, now ask me how many star wars games have been made????, dozens, and has 20 novels or more!!!!!! plus 6 movies!!!!!!!! and many TV variants!!!!, one of the novels tell that the force has no comparison!!!! it even lets u reincarnate on the peoples mind and get control of new bodies!!! even tear down entire planets without aid, even more powerful than the death star, force is just too strong against somepsichyc bastards, they have no chance!!! so jedis and siths just outmatch everything!!!
NOW SUPER WEAPONS, ehm… sorry starcraft has any!, just glassing a planet but takes much more time and an entire fleet, and for the starwars universe, glassing a planet its nothing new!!!!, actually a single star destroyer striked fear on every person on the planet it was orbiting on!!!, it could start operation zero zone and in a matter of minutes it could destroy every sinlge piece of life that have ever existed on it, evaporate oceans AND destroy its atmosphere!!!! rendering it completely inavitable, no conventional resource could be ever gathered for the rest of the planet’s life! and thats just the begining!, we all know death star capability to destroy a planet, but now that rebel-empire war its over ending in alliance we assume that the death star its complete and fully functional! with the capability of hitting even small crusiers with its super laser, and a cooldown of 3 minutes no starcraft fleet could stand even an hour, even if the death star could be catched alone!!!! so starcraft just (as i said) dont stand a chance!!!, now lets think “wow zeg have 6 plantes under its control, well lets blow them all up!!! OK!!”, they blow them all up in like 7 hours, so zerg the most powerful starcraft race its now extinct (finally cause i hate them!).
and!!! thers still one thats not mentioned much but it still exist, the SUN CRUSHER, in can go in a solar system, unload its special neutron torpedos, they borrow under the sun’s core and blow make it a super nova and blow the entire system in a matter of hours, the best thing its that its just a small fighter class ship with indestructible armor and cannot be detected before it cuases the doom of that system!!! so it even dwarfs the death star!!!
haven’t u got enough???!!! thers still the rebels, the wookies, the hutts, the mandalorian, remaining droid armadas… so, even if the empire couldnt do it alone, it still has a lot of backup!!! so just forget it!!!! starcraft doesnt stand a fucking chance!!!!!! understand it!!!
April 18, 2009
#11
Star wars wins here. We do not know anything about the other races in starcraft so they lose by numbers. And star destroyers can glass planets by themselves so……
April 26, 2009
#12
even if we are talking episode 6 of the movie saga the empire along with out death stars would out number all of the starcraft races several times over.
not to mention the rediculus amounts of ground weponry the empire has. AT-AT for example is a giant walkin fotress, armed with two heavy blaster canons and two rapid fire laser canons. along with a complement of up to 30 stormtroopers, and 4 land speeders.
then there are all the tanks, the tie mauler a comicazi tank on treeds, the tie tank which would be a vary light tank. the TX-130 Saber-class fighter tank armed with concusion missls and laser cannons and a point defense laser on the top.
that was just to list a few,
then in space there is the star destroyer, just one of these mighty war ships can keep and entire planet under imperial contol for an idefinit amount of time. with a complment of 9700 storm troopers (thats alot) and it has:
TIE/ln starfighter (48)[1]
TIE/sa bomber (12)[1]
TIE boarding craft (12)[1]
Lambda-class shuttles (8)[5]
Delta-class stormtrooper transports (15)[1]
Assault gunboats (5)[5]
A variable number of Skipray Blastboats
Gamma-class assault shuttle (1+)
Repair and recovery vehicles
Theta-class AT-AT barges
Sentinel-class landing craft (12)[1]
AT-AT walkers (20)[5]
AT-ST walkers (30)[5]
Prefabricated garrison base
its loaded.
April 27, 2009
#13
GUISE!
Who would win out of these two, And I want this coming from a starwars know it all, Who would win in a fight, The third death star vs a fully finished death star 2?
I Can’t see the difference…..Oh and Death star vs Death star 2 vs Death star 3.
Im just wonderin’….
April 27, 2009
#14
Well, I gotta admit that Star Craft will lose this, badly. But I strongly disagree in the whole Jedi/Sith > Protoss thing. I believe that the Star Craft psykers are on a similar caliber to the Warhammer 40k ones.
April 28, 2009
#15
Hello? Any starwars fans there? I need mah question answered.
May 22, 2009
#16
@L-W, Can you elaborate for us how Star Wars would crush Starcraft?
October 3, 2009
#17
hey would the ino cannon help Sc? or that the mother ship in starcraft (portoss side) can spawn a black hole… but yea ino cannon the dark protoss mind control the overmind infechen…hmm…can’t think right now….just mind control the darth vader or something i odn’t know
October 3, 2009
#18
It’s mostly a matter of scale. Most of the fighting in star craft takes place in the Korpulu sector. Fighting in star wars takes place all over the galaxy.
October 3, 2009
#19
The ion Cannon may disable some Imperial ships but it would only slow them down slightly. The black hole ability of the mothership was scrappd and replaced with some sort of vortex attack. The dark templar mind control would not be very useful as it only targets a single ebign and as soon as they turn they will be killed by the empire. The terrans would likely be crippled by the Empire’s plagues so that leaves the zerg. who would be burned to cinders from concentarted blaster fire.
October 10, 2009
#20
Until we know more about Starcraft, this is one sided for Star Wars. We do know that Starcraft has beings that can teleport entire ships, Mind kill over hundreds of people, and crack planets apart, but we only know five major races in Starcraft(including the Xel’naga and the race that was shown in Frontline: 4 which is what Duran is.)
October 10, 2009
#21
Actually we do know a lot about starcraft. We know that hydralisk spines can pierce battlecruiser armor, and that the terrans are generally cannon fodder much weaker in the books compared to what we see in the video games.
and Zerglings can be killed by Angry farmers with some writer favor. Furthermore doesn’t star wars outnumber starcraft horribly by involving the entire galaxy and its population as compared to starcraft where we have conflicts going on in a specific sector of the galaxy.
January 7, 2010
#22
Star Wars, the Protoss are NOTHING. If the weak Zerg can take them and nearly win, the Toss are a series of leaves, against the nuclear storm of the Galactic Empire.
January 8, 2010
#23
wait a minute…. capital ship cloaking is a big effin deal…
and I hardly think that exploding someones mind and causing storms that can eventually consume planets is less than pushing around a rock and choking someone out…
plus protoss capital ships have at least teraton planet cracking capability…
not to mention the empire is disected and leaderless…
this may not be quite the landslide you all think it is
“Star Wars, the Protoss are NOTHING. If the weak Zerg can take them and nearly win, the Toss are a series of leaves, against the nuclear storm of the Galactic Empire.”
cute… lets turn this around
Starcraft, the stormtroopers are nothing, if the weak Ewok can take them and nearly win, the empire is a series of leaves, against the planet cracking mind rape that is Starcraft.
January 14, 2010
#24
Hah some of the best ships of the protoss are greatly outgunned by an outdated medium frigate. Their cloaking has been shown to be able to be cancelled out by terran sensors. The Empire may be leaderless but the rebels and Vong are not. Besides wouldnt Thrawn soon bring the Imps back to glory?
Proof of teraton level firepower?
The protoss and Zerg have been unable to defeat space rednecks, plus the Ewoks had alot of help from rebel agents with some of the strongest plot shielding available.
January 14, 2010
#25
the Chicxulab impact estimated near 100 teratons… and didnt crack into the earths mantle… the protoss crack into a planets mantal… time is unknown but its not slow… its quick enough to not let the flying space capable zerg off the planet before its over…
January 14, 2010
#26
Im still skeptical about the toss having teraton level weapons buts ill let the smart people determine that. Still Starcraft is heavily out numbered. The koprulu sector, according to the starcraft wiki has about 119 worlds. The galacitc empire compromises of million of worlds. plus when you add in the Vong well its just unfair.
January 14, 2010
#27
i didnt say starcraft could win… i just dont think its going to be a curb stomp… they will most likely lose(depending solely on SC2 for any chance of victory…) but they would put up one good fight that would take decades to finish
January 14, 2010
#28
Im doubtful it would take decades. The Vong also have methods of planetary destruction and although the protoss have powerful warships they would be overwhelmed quite quickly. Meanwhile the super plagues of the empire would make short work of the terrans and the zerg would be target practice.
January 14, 2010
#29
/ SW delivers curpstomp./
January 14, 2010
#30
while i disagree… since the protoss can cloak worlds to sensors… it could possibly take decades… how long did it take to find the rebel base?? with the entire empire searching for it???
the dark templar are adept at hiding via there warping space time to cloak….
“the zerg would be target practice…”
considering the can planet jump with ease and reproduce enough to take an entire planet in a week…
it might be a little more difficult than one could imagine…
January 28, 2010
#31
“Hah some of the best ships of the protoss are greatly outgunned by an outdated medium frigate. Their cloaking has been shown to be able to be cancelled out by terran sensors. The Empire may be leaderless but the rebels and Vong are not. Besides wouldnt Thrawn soon bring the Imps back to glory?
Proof of teraton level firepower?
The protoss and Zerg have been unable to defeat space rednecks, plus the Ewoks had alot of help from rebel agents with some of the strongest plot shielding available.”
I think I already gave proof of Protoss Terra-ton levels. Only mechanical cloaking has been detected in lore. There psionic cloaking has not. The Protoss and the Zerg have never went directly for the annialation of the Terrans. They pretty much a road bump compared to the Protoss and the Zerg. The Terran will be directly attacked in the SC2 though.
February 12, 2010
#32
the terran could use the phyemiter to control the minds the jedi and just send them to kill the empire then kill themselves.hahahahahahahahahahahaha!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
March 3, 2010
#33
While I easily give this fight to the SW Universe. The biggest problems in the StarCraft downfall is this:
1. Starkiller: Probably one of the most powerful force users there is, he’d be cleaning out the battlefield whereever the Empire deplored him and it would be quite messy to say the least.
2. The Deathstar: An extremely large battlestation that only has one weakpoint, most forces that come across it don’t come out alive.
3. Sith and Jedis: Powerful force users. ‘Nuff said.
March 17, 2010
#34
For those who say star wars can handle zerg with just the rest of their forces, I’d say its pretty impossible. As zerg is the race which assimilates all other races, the vast variety of races would provide zerg with a chance to upgrade it’s armies. As everybody knows, the most powerful zerg unit (from starcraft I) being hydralisk was evolved by extracting DNA from the sloth-like creatures in a world they took over. I’m pretty sure they could even assimilate the Yuuzhan Vong, meaning that combined with all the other races already under their belt, they can overrun quite a lot of star wars planets.
May 7, 2010
#35
for all you pro star wars i say blow me dark archons have mind control plus wraiths have invisibility and vader would be pwn3d by zeratul and tassadar oh did any1 mention nukes? so guess wut? star wars can suck a defiler 4 all i care the protoss can own anything george lucas can throw at them thx blizzard
May 7, 2010
#36
oh also the ion cannon, yammato cannon carriers, ghost are like jedi with guns and cloak, hello! and the jedi can`t kill in anger the toss can, the zerg are always multiplying and firebats i think flamers could burn through yer little cloak mister jedi
May 7, 2010
#37
well basically siege tanks lock down and to all you pro sc en taro adun!!!
June 11, 2010
#38
*holds up urkburger by the back of his shirt* Ok, who left the door open? A fanboi just wandered in?
June 26, 2010
#39
2 words: Darth Bane
July 31, 2010
#40
Oh I don’t know, I think the Hydrid might have something to say. Did I mention Psionjc Storms?Maybe Ghosts can do something? But the race of creatures (Zerg) that can absorb lifeforms into thier DNA might be a challenge. How do you feel about a Psionically powered Zerg that can use the Force? Or a guy named Samir Duran? You decide.