So, without getting into too many variations, this battle take place with an average pilot – so no Darth Vader piloting the Tie or Master Chief helming the Banshee. Instead, measure the mecha themselves independent of the pilot.
Tie Fighter
- Solar panels power a twin ion engine (TIE)
- Tremendous Speed
- High Maneuverability
- Dual Lasers
Banshee
- Good for anti-vehicle and quick strikes
- Speed Burst
- High Maneuverability
- Plasma Gun
So the question is, which vehicle has the best performance?





May 6, 2008
#1
these aren’t mecha, they’re space ships.
And if banshees work in space like they do in atmosphere, then they’ll lose to the far greater manouverability of Ties.
May 6, 2008
#2
oh yeah biotches first comment. the banshee is good but the tie is just faster, have better maneuvering and have more fire power. The tie gets this one
May 7, 2008
#3
Althoght the banshee is slower then the tie, i think the bashees firepower would prevail. Its got twin plasma lasers and the missle pods
May 9, 2008
#4
Tie wins, hands down. Tie fighters, while mostly used for deep space, are also rated highly for atmospheric combat, especialy the Tie Intercepter. the homing rockets would tear easily through the banshee’s shield, since they’re designed to tear through capital ship shields.
May 20, 2008
#5
tie wins in anay seniro no matter what
May 25, 2008
#6
The TIE wins due to superb fire power. But, just as a side note: TIEs are built cheap so that the Empire can have mass quantities of them. The life support systems are weak and short lived and there is no hyperdrive installed (save Vader’s Advance TIE fighter and a few others… The “no hyperdrive” was to give the fighters more caution when fighting, knowing that they could not back out…it also cut back on expenses!
May 27, 2008
#7
how the hell did you find out that much,are you geek?
May 27, 2008
#8
TIE wins. I don’t see no troopers feat sticking out the back, ha!
June 1, 2008
#9
It’s like comparing a jet fighter to a crop duster!! The Banshee doesn’t have a chance!
July 26, 2008
#10
the TIE fighter has a lot less armor than a Banshee but it makes it up for speed. but the banshee is fast and strong, sure a rocket, laser, turret on a warthog but u cant take out a banshee with a magnum, a TIE fighter can be destroyed in a couple laser shots, plus wouldnt plasma fire from the banshee melt the hull, thus suffocating the pilot?
July 29, 2008
#11
They’re both too generic and flimsy as fighter craft go for anyone to notice who won…
August 6, 2008
#12
m cant take the banshee with a magnum? ever play a little game called halo combat evolved then again the magnum is like a portable deathstar
August 8, 2008
#13
hm depends on pilot.
hey how bout arwing(star fox)vs X-wing
added to the list. Thanks! Admin
August 26, 2008
#14
dude i did play the first halo! im talking about halo 2 and halo 3 where the banshee does have speed boost! oh and only n00bs use the magnum!
September 7, 2008
#15
A banshee is udes for batles on a planet,it’s not used for space batlles
seraph vs tie fighter
December 18, 2008
#16
neither win they just stay in there hangars coz noones flyin them… then chuck norris jumps in and breaks them then flys away… coz everyone noes chuck norris can fly
December 30, 2008
#17
OMG this is possibly the most epic battle ever isnt that right bob? yep sure is.
and a turn ooo! The banshee took a shot to the wing. what is that thing in the sky looking at us?! ( this is c ling cat tarets sighted…..locked launch the ATTACK CATS! meeeeoooooowwwwwww!!!!!!!!!!!!! omg bob theres blurs in the sky! sure tim! there gone, wered the ships go? omg there in the cat litter, do you see that bob!…… bob…….. bob? no i dont cause im buried in cat litter. that must be great bob! sure is tim, sure is.
January 2, 2009
#18
Banshee cause it has missiles
May 6, 2009
#19
“banshee because it has missiles” (-.-) ,,!,,
the tie fighter has missiles too dumbass!
May 14, 2009
#20
this would never happen because fighters are made for space battles banshees are made for atmospereic dog fights thats why when you look up in the air and you see banshees and hornets battleing in the sky and never in space. The banshee would win though. A banshee has better fire power plus a built in fuel rod cannon that emmits radiation and in halo 3 tracks you for a short time.
October 6, 2009
#21
And you do know what starwars tech totally outclasses halos?
If an DC-15 (hand held rifle) can shoot torso sized holes in “something harder than concrete” something bigger, aka the tie fighter’s laser cannons will have no problems taking down a banshee.
1 shot from a tie fighter can take down the banshee.(Source: Go read the starwars vs halo thread) And this depends on which tie fighter they are talking about, empire or new republic. one has shields and rockets, the other doesnt.
Either way, the totally technological disparity gives the win to starwars’s tie fighter.
October 6, 2009
#22
“And you do know that starwars tech totally outclasses halos?”
sorry about the typo error.
November 21, 2009
#23
banshee wins faster,agile,and basicly tie fighters are easily destroyed because of those large solar panneld wings
November 21, 2009
#24
sry because its faster ect…
November 21, 2009
#25
“sry because its faster ect…”
http://cdn.buzznet.com/assets/users16/ignatz/default/cheese-cat-fail–large-msg-119620326139.jpg
Before you talk out of your ass again, please know that the banshee’s top-speed in atmosphere is a little over 100 km/h, where as the TIE’s is around 1,200 km/h.
“banshee wins faster,agile,and basicly tie fighters are easily destroyed because of those large solar panneld wings”
TIEs are armored with durasteel, which is a metal with one-hundred times the tensile strength of modern titainium; The banshee wouldn’t even scratch the TIE… Plus we’ve been through the firepower gap between SW and Halo.
The TIE wins here… big time.
November 21, 2009
#26
I am going to go get pop-corn ready, prop up a nice pillow, and wait for the doom that is L-W to come upon this thread…….going to be quite a show.
- the pondering fool
November 21, 2009
#27
@PF
I can’t wait either… er… And before he does come though, I’d like to say that the TIE’s plating is actually made of a titainium alloy… Not durasteel.
‘wipes sweat from brow’
November 21, 2009
#28
“@PF
I can’t wait either… er… And before he does come though, I’d like to say that the TIE’s plating is actually made of a titainium alloy… Not durasteel.
‘wipes sweat from brow’”
Good thing you caught that mistake before….he who must not be named, found out. Well, they say patience is key, so I guess I must wait…..
- the pondering fool
November 21, 2009
#29
“Good thing you caught that mistake before….he who must not be named, found out. Well, they say patience is key, so I guess I must wait…..”
’shudder’
Yeah, though I still have to deal with my own irony… I think the only TIE model that even had reinforced durasteel plates was Vader’s TIE… BUT, this is SW grade titanium we’re talking about… I need a drink.
November 21, 2009
#30
i saw it but didnt say anything
November 21, 2009
#31
“i saw it but didnt say anything”
Thanks, but it’s a secret to everyone… Oh crap, my schizophrenia is acting up again.
January 23, 2010
#32
For all you dumbasses who think TIE fighters have missles, they don’t. They only have 2 LS-1 light laser cannons
January 24, 2010
#33
well TIE me up and call me an Elite i guess the T Fighters do wtfpwn Banshees
January 27, 2010
#34
I’ll make this quick and fast: Tie fighters fire concentrated energy which is known as blaster bolts, this is originates from Plasma, but it is a much higher concentrated level, and is also “excited” by components in the firing mechanism which makes it much more deadly than the weaponry that is fired off from all Covenant weaponry including fuel rod cannons, Tie fighters are built to basically absorb all that and basically it could just fire off a few shots to destroy the Banshee, and they are much faster and maneuverable.