Suggested by Blood Dancer
Surprisingly, this is only the second time Sam Fisher has appeared in a match on this site. This match isn’t a fight, but instead it’s a match to see who’s stealth ability would win out over the other. To make it interesting, the scenario is that the objective is located on the 11th floor of a 21 story hotel. Snake starts at the bottom, and Fisher starts from the roof.
Who gets there first?





August 1, 2009
#1
admin, r there gaurds? if so what type of gaurds?
– Guards? Yes. type: Top level – assume they’re protecting something extremely valuable. – Admin
August 1, 2009
#2
Solid snake.
/thread
August 1, 2009
#3
Due to outrageous skills and moves that Solid Snake use to butcher hundreds of Special Forces and a bunch of Notorious charaters in Metal Gear, well, I will say he is better than his NSA counterpart.
August 1, 2009
#4
Damn my two favorite secret agents going against each other. Well the only way to figure out who wins this one is by flipping a coin.
August 1, 2009
#5
I would say snake could more easily move through the hotel,do both start with all equipment?
“do both start with all equipment?” – Yes. Admin
August 1, 2009
#6
If Snake has all his equipment, then it would be really easy for him to sneak through seeing how he not only uses Octo Camo blend with his surrounding colors, textures, and temperature but also the Stealth device giving him the ability to run around like predator without the whole water issue.
Add the infinite ammo Bandanna,the tranquilizer pistol, and chaff grenades and Snake just disabled all the surveillance.
August 1, 2009
#7
then i would think snake
August 1, 2009
#8
“do both start with all equipment?” – Yes. Admin”
Well then I guess the Snake’s carboard box will be of most help to him then.
August 1, 2009
#9
“Well then I guess the Snake’s carboard box will be of most help to him then.”
and then wearing stealth camouflage under that.
August 1, 2009
#10
Given all of the equipment and gear..Snake will make Sam look like a recruit with high tech gear that can turn him basicaly into a ghost, the bandana ( How the hell does this thing give him unlimited ammo??), Patriot, “Magazines” , Box, barrel,
Sam is eventually look at the magazine right?
I see it like this snake gets there first..
Owns in close range combat with the crazy CQC
Unlimited ammo from ANY gun with the bandana
If not the patriot
stealth camo
And Snake has taken down Giant Robots, Superior Baddies and even supernatrual people (sorrow, Vulcan, Crazy mantis etc)
But i havent played mgs 1 or 4 yet so yah thats what i got
August 2, 2009
#11
I wonder are there any bosses in this match
August 2, 2009
#12
“(sorrow, Vulcan, Crazy mantis etc)”
It’s Psycho Mantis
August 2, 2009
#13
@Monkey of DOOM!: your facts are all out of whack.
August 2, 2009
#14
Why would Snake need camo?
Carboard box and he sneaks up on Sam.
August 4, 2009
#15
@The One Sin
Maybe, not a fact at all…..
August 10, 2009
#16
Im not giving facts im giving my opinons of the match up..you dont have to try to rip a person out inside out
August 10, 2009
#17
“Why would Snake need camo?
Carboard box and he sneaks up on Sam.”
or he could use the oil drum and roll him over. then be sick.
August 27, 2009
#18
In real world Sam Fisher would win, He has all tricks up his sleeve. and will use most fastest way to get out of 11th floor.
His gadgets are far more simple to use. where as Snake is a worthy competitor he lacks natural sense of stealth.
Sam Fisher – Stealth.
Snake – butt kicking
A fight between both may be a draw but stealth Sam Fisher WINS!!
August 27, 2009
#19
Would you care to explain why Snake has ‘no natural sense of stealth’ ?
August 27, 2009
#20
@Shail
i’m with Asger on this one. Enlighten us about his lack of natural sense for stealth.
November 7, 2009
#21
Sam Fisher would win in the real world as snake is completely unrealistic while fisher is actually realistic. Fisher relies on stealth a lot more while Snake just ties to kill everyone. I would put snake as more of a supers soldier than spy.
November 16, 2009
#22
Snake is just faster, more stealthy, stronger and admin said all gear so he has stealth camo…
November 16, 2009
#23
I think Sam will win this one but only because of his starting position. Snake has to go up 10 floors while Sam has to descend 10 floors. Snake will have to either take the stairs, elevator, or scale the outside of the building; Sam just tosses a rope over the side and repells down a floor in a second or two. Sam (almost put Samus) just has a significantly easier path to take, and Snake cannot produce vertical movement upwards as quickly as Sam can produce vertical movement downwards. It helps greatly that gravity is on Sam’s side too.
Once inside the building Sam will have to slow down greatly, but since he can get to the 11th floor so much quicker than Snake can I doubt it will effect him all that much. If Snake books it in full stealth camo right from the get go (assuming the guards don’t have thermal optics) then he might be able to get to the 11th floor close to the time Sam is picking up the objective.
November 16, 2009
#24
dumb dumb dumb…. Sam will repel down the side of the building, crash through the window after his silenced pistol makes a few head shots… crashes through the broken window, snags the easter eggs and finishes repeling…
snake be in his box in the elevator on the first floor by the time this all goes down…
December 11, 2009
#25
Realistically: Sam
Fictionally: Snake
January 18, 2010
#26
Snake would win cause 1. He is a clone of 1 of the best troops 2.He can take down an enemy that has a rail gun, a RAIL GUN! 3.He could kill Fisher then leave his body hanging off a flag poll! 4.Hes AWSOMEx9000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
January 30, 2010
#27
I’ve played with both and Fishers got it all the way. Yes i’ve played with Snake, took out people in plain daylight, used all the weapons to get to the target, but Fisher takes it from there. Snake gets dropped into forrests to eat rats, snakes, birds, all so he wont fizzle out and die. Sam is sent into high priority areas up front, big bomb holding tankers, UN buildings, major arms dealers head quarters , a double agents in a warehouse with nothing but the enemy. They don’t give a crap about grass crawlin’, salt lickin’ multi-cloned Solid Snake, lol. If you had the choice to become one of the two, who would you choose, Snake (someone who can be seen shooting at you?) or Fisher (someone who’s shooting at you from WHO KNOWS WHERE)? I’d pick the all stealthy, Splinter Cell. Just coming from the side who’s creator has made 5 star movies time after time.