Sorry I’ve been gone for a while.
Anyway, I think this one goes to the clown. Rorschach simply isn’t as clever as the Joker, and he’d need to go through a lot of henchmen to even approach him. Plus the Joker has a ridiculous amount of weaponry such as rocket launchers, joker venom, etc. that could take out Rorschach with little difficulty.

I agreed with Kenny C. that the chances are 50-50 however I think Joker will pull it off. Because the Joker even though has been known to plan out his attacks he is also to be random or at least his foes think that what he does is random. So I think because of that the Joker will win granted it will be bloodist fight of the century.

while id like to think Rorschach will win he dose not follow the same code as batman and for some bazaar reason when ever someone like that goes up against the joker they end up dead. it as if batman is the only person meant to counter joker. as if it was only he who has the power to kill joker but wont because he knows no man is meant to decide who lives or dies. any way while Rorschach is incredibly resourceful and clever (maybe even more so than batman in some cases) i honestly cant see him killing joker. maybe in some odd complex game of cat and mouse Rorschach would die attempting to kill joker and succeed. but that’s as close to victory as he gets. in the end joker gets the last laugh.

why so serious?

this fights outcome is completely dependent on the situation i think

I think Joker would have trouble fighting Rorschach.He’s a completely different opponent to Batman.He’s just a ruthless and crazy as Joker,but it’s a completely different type of crazy.

I’d give the win to Rorschach,due to sheer rescourcefulness and unpredictability.

For those of you who say Rorschach/Joker wins, I agree with both. Rorschach and the Joker are both crazy, but Rorschach has an understanding to what he says in both the graphic novel and the movie, WATCHMEN. He is strong, very agile, and when he has to,” No Compromise!” Rorschach is as resourceful as the Joker, and can adapt and use his environment. In the graphic novel and the movie he shows little pain in Antarctica, and the fight with Ozymandias.The Joker is as unpredictable as Rorschach, but most environments he cannot adapt to, and does not know Rorschach. No one in DC Universe knows Rorschach, therefore The Joker will never see him coming, with his face on or off. Sure, the Joker is a mastermind, But Rorschach can see past his tricks, lies, and make-up. Rorschach will hunt you down if you committed a crime without justice, and Jokers committed plenty. Rorschach wins, but in DC, Marvel, etc. there is always alternate worlds, dimensions, realities, etc. so everyone wins. Rorschach wins in this fight though.

I agree with the general consensus.

Rorschach is a capable and resourceful enough detective to flush out or track down the Joker, and with no outside help or the like, he’ll be eating some knuckles soon after the meeting.

I don’t think he has any equipment either on his person that would be helpful.

If I recall correctly, that flower on his lapel does shoot acid out. But I don’t think a squirt of acid is going to be something Rorschach can’t deal with. Even if it hits him, he has the physical strength and personality to crush Joker’s skull or break something almost in an instant.

Rorschach for FP award.

Whoops, I meant he could talk Rorschach to death.

Who would put joker in a fist fight we all know the joker can’t fight.. We should put the bum rorschach against batman

@Chuck inglish
He is against the Punisher…

@Sparks
Well let’s put him up against Bruce Wayne or frank castle when they are unarmed without any weapons nor costume…just a fist fight

Both of those people can beat Rorschach in a fist fight, and if it’s currently Frankencastle (which is now some monster type thing) it’s even more of a curbstomp.

I’d say Marv is one of Rorschach’s most even opponents, the debate kind of died since no one cares greatly enough about either, but neither one outclasses the other in a significant enough fashion.

Look around for some more unstable folks to fight with Rorschach, that aren’t completely out of his league like Frank and Bruce.

@Sparks
Rorschach wins that one too…

Not against Batman or Frankencastle he doesn’t.

The Marv one, could go either way. Rorschach has the bonus feat of going up against someone tougher than anyone in Sin City (Ozy) even though he got wrecked. But, I can’t make that call since I don’t know a significant deal about both others.

But Punisher severely outclasses Rorschach in brute power, and Batman severely outclasses Rorschach in technique and combat skill/prowess.

I gotta go, but will be back tomorrow…

Hm..

lol it might be, I know Brock is batshit crazy, but he’s taken out armies before. For isntance, do you think 10-15 policemen could take down Brock Samson?

eh.. that may be more of a stomp than Batman fighting him.

Maybe The Question would be okay, I think he’s based off of him anyway. I know nothing about The Question though.