FactPile

Dark Light
Ori Warship Vs Executor
Ori Warship Vs Executor

Suggested by Ryan
This is a match that I would just love to sit back with some snacks and a frosty beverage and watch the show.

Who wins?

Rate This Post:

44 Comments
  • Dracosphinx
    October 25, 2009
    #1

    To tell the truth… I have no Idea who would win

  • Sam the heretic
    October 25, 2009
    #2

    As MJ would have put it…

    You are not alone…

  • shaun182
    October 25, 2009
    #3

    since i dont know the energy output of the ori weapon compared to the executor’s sheilds its hard to say but i have witnessed ori shields take a hell of a lot of punishment i know SW ship weapons have a higher energy output compared to a lot of other vessels also the executor is far larger meaning it could take a lot more damage and still be a considerable threat

    so i would imagine it would come down to the ori ship making a quick critical hit to the executors generator or bridge or the executor destroying the ori in long drawn out fight

  • Skrunks
    October 25, 2009
    #4

    My money’s on the Executor. While the main cannon of the Ori ship has enough juice to obliterate a Go’uld Mothership with even a glancing blow, a Go’uld ship is no where near the same ball game as the Executor. I’d estimate that cannon is equivalent to a few dozen turbolasers at best, likely much lower.

    A better match up would be an Ori Mothership agianst a Star Destroyer or something. But against the Executor?

  • Cpt Olimar
    October 25, 2009
    #5

    couldn’t this match just end with the executor slamming into the ori vessel at FTL speeds?

    Since I believe the executor survived a similar impact from another SW ship, but I’m only going by what I’ve read people say on other threads.

  • Dracosphinx
    October 25, 2009
    #6

    This is my box of Nabisco Flavor Originals Chicken in a Biskit.

    Do not reach into this box and grab a cracker or I will chop your hands off and watch you bleed to death in my kitchen.

    I am not even kidding. As a matter of fact, if you look at this box in a way I feel threatened, I’ll take a rusty scratch awl from my toolbox and ram it into one of your eyeballs. As you scream in pain, I will snack on the delicious treat while holding the telephone arms length away from you to get the medical dire treatment you need.

    What are you doing? Are you eyeing my snack crackers? I can sense it in you.

    Before you question my ability to respond in such a manner, you should know that the last person who placed his hand on my box of Chicken in a Biskit snacks was found dismembered and placed into local restaurant trash receptacles in four different states.

    A former friend I had merely questioned me politely for a taste of the delectable treat. That night, I saw to it that his house burned to the ground with his entire family inside. I nearly felt bad when I heard the loud thudding and screams coming from behind the doors I had barricated shut. The box of treats is less than the cost of materials I used as an accelerant to torch the home of my ex-friend. But this is action was based principle, not economics.

    Maybe you might think you can go to one of a variety of local establishments, such as gas stations or grocery stores, to get your own package of Chicken in a Biskit crackers. You could do this, of course. As long as I don’t know you do it, because you should understand that if I know you like Chicken in a Biskit as I do; you’re more likely to dip into a future box of mine when my back is turned. This cannot stand! I will not back down or relent in defending my box of scrumptious munchies.

    I’m watching you.

  • Pondering Fool
    October 25, 2009
    #7

    Uhhmmmm……wow, i just don’t know how Post #6 is related to the thread…….very creepy though……Anyway, from what I have read in these threads, I do know that the Executor is damn powerful (read the What if threads: Executor going into UNSC space. It was quite enlightening). But I have no knowledge on Ori Warship….so I can’t say anything……

    - the pondering fool

  • Fooby
    October 25, 2009
    #8

    The Ori Ship could win if it could manage a shot into the bridge, otherwise no

  • Space marine
    October 25, 2009
    #9

    Oh shuddup Draco.

    *Tackles*

    Yum. *Eats whatever he was defending*

  • Dracosphinx
    October 25, 2009
    #10

    *stabs space marine in the eyeball with a rusty awl*
    DON”T TOUCH MY DAMN CHICKIN BISKITS!!!!!!

  • swifterdeath
    October 25, 2009
    #11

    *Eats chicken biscuit then proceeds to shoot self in head* Ha! Im already dead you cant kill me!

  • shaun182
    October 25, 2009
    #12

    sets fire to the chicken biskit factory
    there now no one can have any now are you happy

  • Dracosphinx
    October 25, 2009
    #13

    @Shaun.
    Shut up.*sarcastic tone*

  • Locutus
    October 25, 2009
    #14

    The Giant Toilet of Doom’s super-heated urine cannon could do some major damage on the Executor.

  • Skrunks
    October 25, 2009
    #15

    Funny, I could have sworn that the website said ‘Factpile’ on the name, not ‘Spampile’

    http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3183/2346967847_76ebb71443.jpg?v=0

  • Who?
    October 25, 2009
    #16

    Mmmm… Spam….

  • shaun182
    October 25, 2009
    #17

    yes quick back to the topic at hand before L-W comes along with list of reasons he’s right and why we are retards

  • L-W
    October 25, 2009
    #18

    You’re a retard.

    I didn’t really have any reason for saying that, in fact it was more of a knee jerk reaction.

    - – -

    Anyway, without a base comparison on firepower (for now) I would struggle to determine an accurate appraisal of Executor shield strength versus Ori power generation; however from a previous thread I did surmise that one Acclamator I-class assault ship would be equal to about 200 Goa’uld Ha’tak warships in terms of firepower.

    Now from canon we know that the Executor is twenty years more advanced than an Acclamator, is a thousand times the size, generates over four thousand times more energy, has five thousand more weapons emplacements and possesses a thousand times the firepower and shield generation capabilities.

    Make of that what you will.

    - – -

    “so i would imagine it would come down to the ori ship making a quick critical hit to the executors generator or bridge or the executor destroying the ori in long drawn out fight”

    1) We have no understanding of Ori firepower (only that it outclasses Goa’uld/US/Russian space technology) and how it would interact with petaton-exaton level shielding.

    2) The Executor (as with most Star Destroyers) can operate without the bridge, they are designed to be like cockroaches, capable of scuttling around and fighting back even when the head has been removed.

  • Skrunks
    October 25, 2009
    #19

    The only neutral ground I can think of when it comes to Ori Firepower is oribtal bombardment. In order to make any sort of dent in the Executor shields, it would need to have much higher firepower then what was shown in the bombardment of Dakara: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wrf39VEMGCA

    However I believe that the weapons were on some sort of low-power setting, because those same blasts utterly obliterated Go’uld motherships. Having said that, like L-W just said, that doesn’t take much by Starwars standards. I doubt that Ori cannon of death is much stronger then a single tubrolaser.

  • L-W
    October 26, 2009
    #20

    I agree, that seemed to be more of a surgical strike than a mass bombardment; which seems to indicate sub-kiloton yields in the order of only a few hundred tons of TNT at the most.

  • Skrunks
    October 26, 2009
    #21

    Considering that the Ori are capable of crushing planets into black holes, I really don’t know how to judge the firepower on these ships. Hmm… the Prometheus could tank a few shots, because of the Asgardian shields, but excessive bombardment from Goa’uld ships are capable of damaging the ship. In order for the Ori ships to be able to even scracth the Executor, they would have to tear the ship apart. The very fact that Goa’uld weapons can damage the Promethus, and the Promtheus can take a direct hit from the Ori ship proves that it wouldn’t be able to stand up to the Executor. An Imperial Star Destroyer might be a different story, because the Goa’uld weapons were upgraded by Anubis in season 6 or something, and L-W’s calculations may have been based on the weapons before that. *shrugs*

    I’m gonna vote Executor cause it’s bigger.

  • David
    October 26, 2009
    #22

    Can I just say that, Draco, you are a creepy bastard with those werid snacks and you need so rehab ASAP. Because you know what they say about rehab. Rehab is for quitters.

    Ok back on topic.

    Vanilla Ice ice baby…….. Ooops

    And skrunks. I agree

  • flyboy51
    October 26, 2009
    #23

    I believe the Ori ship would punch few good holes in the Executor, but due to its massive size the latter would win as it would counterattack with devastating amounts of firepower.

  • AlphaCommando
    October 26, 2009
    #24

    “Now from canon we know that the Executor is twenty years more advanced than an Acclamator, is a thousand times the size, generates over four thousand times more energy, has five thousand more weapons emplacements and possesses a thousand times the firepower and shield generation capabilities.”

    Be afraid, be very afraid. We’re talking about atomization of the foe in a single volley.

    One track I think we need to get off of is putting enemies up against the EXECUTOR of all things, sure its not the Death Star but it’s considerably more powerful than most ships in Star Wars which is a universe several stages above many other sci-fi universes. I think we need to stick to standard Star Destroyers unless the foe is very very powerful.

  • shaun182
    October 26, 2009
    #25

    so i think we are in agreement that even thou the ori have a pretty powerful weapon however it is far out matched in size and armament by the executor

    @admin- pehaps star destroyer vs command carrier(farscape) would be a more equal fight

  • Tim
    October 26, 2009
    #26

    How would the Executor fare against a Culture Ocean Class GSV?

  • Wtfmachine
    October 26, 2009
    #27

    end of what season nine of stargate is it? three ori ships PWND what? one earth battleship one Azgard battleship and i think what 5-9 Hat’ak battleships?
    that was three ori ships

    plus the only way where they sucessfully destroyed one took luck and skill, they used a stargate in the pegasis galaxy to open up another stargate Milky way to open up the super gate wich destroyed a wraith hive and an ori battleship at the same time.
    We don’t have very good intel on the ori weaponery other than it as ship to starfighter weapons and a super lazer that would tear through a gou’uld hat’ack vessle (through shileds and all)

    (ok i lied)

    with out azgard technology the earth ship still going would have never made it one more battle (this was the end of seaon ten) though the use of the azgard technology made the earthship like a beacon telling the ori where they are and what they are doing. the azgard beam weapon is sucsesful in destroy the Replicators V2 ( pegasis galaxy) and did well in destroying Ori ships

    but do we really know if the super star destroyer has weapons that are greater or more advanced than the azgard beam weapon? well L-W might i just don’t know

    all we know is that the main weapon on the Ori cruiser has sucessful potentiial against any SW vehicle.

    though only one ori ship may not be the wisest to go against such an over kill of a ship, maybe 2 or 3.

  • Skrunks
    October 26, 2009
    #28

    The problem is wtfmachine is that a single turbolaser would have the same effect as the Ori main gun agianst a Hat’ak, it would tear through it’s shields and hull with a single shot. The Executor has thousands of turbolaser and heavy turbolaser emplacements. It just couldn’t handle that kind of firepower. And the Asgaurd Beam weapons are ultra fine precision weapons designed to penetrate shields with molecule wide high powered blasts, I think that those weapons would be fully capable of penetrating the Executor’s shields as well, but in terms of raw firepower, I don’t think they have a lot of punch,

  • Wtfmachine
    October 27, 2009
    #29

    @skrunks

    well one thing’s for certian, azgard were a race of technology and cloning. “died” out when they cloned to much. except in the fianl e season of atlantis.

    i think that the high manuverability could easily get into some potential blind spots on the Executor ( but it would be still visible except in most parts of the Ori)

    i’d say a few ori vessles would be able to defete the executor

  • Sapper007
    October 27, 2009
    #30

    I seriously doubt there are many “blind spots” on the Executor… in fact I would say up until your within ‘piss-on-the-hull’ range… you are pretty much in the cross fire of 6 or so different weapon emplacements…

  • Skrunks
    October 27, 2009
    #31

    “i think that the high manuverability could easily get into some potential blind spots on the Executor ( but it would be still visible except in most parts of the Ori)”

    Considering that the Executor has a range of several light minutes (a few million km) on it’s bigger guns, the chances of any capital ship ‘maneuvring’ is slime to none, not to mention the numerous Proton Torpedo tubes.

  • shaun182
    October 27, 2009
    #32

    it might be interesting if the could get a prior or perhaps the orici herself onto the executor depending if she was on this particular ship

  • Skrunks
    October 27, 2009
    #33

    An all out war of the Ori vs. The Empire would be very entertaining, but as far as a single Ori Mothership vs. the Executor? I don’t think it’s going to come out of this one alive.

  • shaun182
    October 27, 2009
    #34

    i agree a single ori ship has a snow ball’s chance in hell of beating the executor however a ground based conflict might be a different

    (i believe a replicators-milky way version vs star wars would make a good debate)

  • L-W
    October 27, 2009
    #35

    Well ranged fire isn’t an issue when it comes to attacking the blind spot of the vessel, but as was demonstrated in the battle of Endor, their trench guns can plug fighters moving in at 6000 G’s below the turret arc of fire.

    In fact the only conceivable blind spot would be to hug the thrusters, but I doubt the Ori warship would survive getting close to a dozen giant exhaust vents spewing out reactant hypermatter at 1.13 TPa (or 60km/s); it would be like a planet sized hair dryer set to overkill.

  • orpheus12
    October 27, 2009
    #36

    500 Internal Server Error
    Sorry, something went wrong.

    A team of highly trained monkeys has been dispatched to deal with this situation.

    Also, please include the following information in your error report:
    Executor wins

  • orpheus12
    October 27, 2009
    #37

    I think i might be doing this for a while.
    its short simple and gets rihgt to the point.
    Unless there are better phrases.
    Any “ideas” ?

  • Wtfmachine
    October 28, 2009
    #38

    short simple really doesn’t work. first off where’s your proof? do you have proof on why the executor wins? other thana team of monkeys with an internet 500 server error?

    could the ori use some sort of virus to infect the net worked computer on the executer?
    @L-W
    not saying that the ori ship has to be right in it’s engine, how bout a little further off? but then it has sheilds so that solves the hull integrity problem.

    isn’t there som way how the ori could use lazer blasts to redirect into their sheilds or power sorces?

  • Sapper007
    October 29, 2009
    #39

    “it would be like a planet sized hair dryer set to overkill.”

    Zohan: I just want to make the galactic empire silky-smooth!

  • shaun182
    October 29, 2009
    #40

    head and shoulders when the dark side is not enough

  • Anti_Halo_Fan_Boy
    November 2, 2009
    #41

    lol agreed, what type of conditioner do you use?

  • flyboy51
    November 2, 2009
    #42

    Several Ori ships VS the Executor would win…but the Executor is usually supported by several Star Destroyers…

    hmmm I thought of two interesting things…

    Ascended Plane in Stargate VS The Force
    What if the Empire discovered Stargate Technology, more specifically the Supergate?

  • Omega-88
    November 3, 2009
    #43

    Executor would win.

    the Executor has more stronger weapons than the ori warship.

    weapons:Over 5,000 turbolaser batteries and ion cannons
    2000 turbolaser batteries
    2000 heavy turbolaser batteries
    250 heavy ion cannons
    500 point-defense laser cannons
    250 heavy concussion missile batteries
    40 Phylon Transport Q7 tractor beam projectors

    Complement: 144 various TIE series starfighters
    TIE/ln starfighters
    TIE/sa bombers
    TIE/In interceptors
    TIE/D Defenders
    TIE/ad starfighters
    Darth Vader’s TIE Advanced x1
    200 miscellaneous combat and support ships
    Gamma-class ATR-6 assault transports
    Lambda-class T-4a shuttles
    Y-85 Titan dropships
    3 prefabricated garrison bases
    Hundreds of heavy walkers
    All Terrain Armored Transports
    All Terrain Scout Transports
    All Terrain Personal Transports
    Various speeder bikes and other ground vehicles
    Supplies for 300,000 individuals
    50,000 heavy concussion missiles

    Crew 279,144
    1,590 gunners
    10,000 droids

    Minimum crew 50,000

    Passengers 38,000 (ground troops)
    501st Legion
    Blizzard Force.

    crew:279,144
    1,590 gunners
    10,000 droids.

  • Pat
    February 3, 2010
    #44

    Might as well put it out there:

    Executor vs Ori ship (No Prior) = Executor wins by sheer brute force

    Executor vs Ori ship (With Prior) = The complete power of a million ascended beings channeled from Prior to shipboard weapons.
    Executor destroyed in one shot.

    So if put that way, and assuming Ascenscion and Force are not related / comparable, the Executor could only win if in the Milky Way due to the Ancients’ cancellation of direct Ori power. The Ori ship would win in SW galaxy.

Leave a Reply:



By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. Please try to keep the language on the clean side - for the most part, you can say what you want and use an * instead of a key vowel, and we'll know what you meant to say. Thanks!


«   |   »
Categories
Heads Up Recent Posts Latest Comments Most Popular Topics Polls

What's more important in a console game?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...