FactPile

Dark Light
Master Chief vs General Grievous
Master Chief vs General Grievous

Great match up here. A light saber master equipped with four arms should present the Chief with some new issues to deal with.

Master Chief

  • Various weapon skills
  • Cool Armor
  • Decent Vehicles
  • Lone Wolf Mentality
  • Has shields to re-generate

General Grievous

  • Brilliant strategist
  • Knows all seven main forms of lightsaber combat
  • Arrogant
  • Powerful fighter
  • Unorthodox fighting form

So can MC survive this fight?

Rate This Post:

150 Comments
  • Steven
    June 22, 2009
    #1

    Grievous would win, easily. He has advanced senses, like chief, he’s powerful enough to rip open metal plating on Captial Ships, he can survive forever in space, he can survive DIRECT Turbolaser shots, his armor is blaster and lightsaber resistant, and he’s an android. He can get repairs faster than chief.

    Chief does have shields, weapons, armor, but it wouldn’t matter. Plasma grenades would just dent Grievous’ armor, Spartan Laser would knock him on his ass, but not FULLY kill him if he had his real chest plating (Star Wars Clone Wars Cartoon that was made before Epi. 3. He has a full chest covering), and there you go.

    Grievous would win.

  • HK-47
    July 11, 2009
    #2

    I also thing Grievous would win this. His ability to wield 4 sabers is deadly, not to mention his skills with them. The Chief would have to keep grievous off and continue to fall back as GG closed in. Bullets from the assault and battle rifles would most probrably ping off of grievous.

    Winner: Grievous

  • Zervziel
    August 3, 2009
    #3

    Gotta love it when plot demands a badass die in the stupidest ways. Ripa Morumee, the Arbiter from Halo Wars and General Grievous would be an awesome fight. Both are arrogant, both have a tendency to back hand subordinates when they hear things they do not like, both liked to duel wield swords, and both of them despite being much loved characters had to die for the convenience of the plot. Ripa in game is a threat to everyone in the immediate vicinity. How about a little vs action between the two, Admin?

  • Zervziel
    August 10, 2009
    #4

    I never voiced who I thought would win did I? It depends on the situation. Plus people have to remember Grievous is packing. his blaster pistol, which is pretty damn powerful for a pistol in the SW universe and if you’ve followed the Halo Vs SW threads, you’ll know it’d be devastating in the Halo universe. Plus if Grievous and MC had access to all their equipment and vehicles, Grievous would definatly win.

  • w2drs21
    August 11, 2009
    #5

    General Grievous was one of the best fighters in the SW universe. He MASTERED all 7 main forms of light saber fighting. He is faster, stronger and more agile than master chief. He also as superior technology. Grievous could Jump in the air and land on MC. Leaving a pile of crushed metal.

    I am talking about grievous in full health.

  • w2drs21
    August 27, 2009
    #6

    Could L-W this admin? I think there has been a good discussion. I think overall grievous has won.

    thanks
    -w2drs21

  • W2DRS21
    August 27, 2009
    #7

    Could you f-p award grievous admin? I did not mean to say l-w.

    thanks -w2drs21

  • Cpt Olimar
    August 28, 2009
    #8

    Grievous really has this in the bag, armor to make MC jealous, weapons to put the energy sword to shame, and firepower to put even the fable Splazer on the shelves to dust. While MC might be able to match Grievous’s speed for a short while, it will take just one mistake for a lightsaber to knock off a limb or worse, from there Grievous takes an easy win.

    and lol @ my post on 91. I actually thought MC might win this :(

  • w2drs21
    August 28, 2009
    #9

    thanks cpt olimar for supporting general grievous!
    also do you know how to get a topic an award. I already requested it an nothing happened.

    -w2drs21

  • Cpt Olimar
    August 28, 2009
    #10

    an FP award requires several “nominations” and the attention of the admin. Since we have a new autopost system in progress, admin will have to independently find this thread (before he approved every post and thus would be notified of nominations). Maybe you could e-mail him about the various threads you deem worthy of FP awards. However, this thread would require at least 2 more nominations.

  • Bob Smith
    September 7, 2009
    #11

    Grevious would just slice MCs guns in half and and cut where MC has no armor

  • w2drs21
    September 8, 2009
    #12

    mcs armor would not protect him from his light sabers.

  • AHEM
    December 9, 2009
    #13

    Well, it’s Star Wars against Halo, so even the massive technological disparity should put MC at a clear disadvantage, even wtihout Grievous’s incredible maneuverability and speed. I say Star Wars takes another win against the Haloverse.

  • kaleb
    January 14, 2010
    #14

    I think that the MC would win simply because you cant see a buller flying twords you and also even if the AR fails he can take out the trusty sniper rifle and put aq bullet betwwen grevisuos eyes. but he would have to keep his distance

  • Zervziel
    January 15, 2010
    #15

    @ Kaleb

    Vs matches are considered arena matches effectively. In other words, MC can’t scamper off to go hide behind some bushes and wait hoping that General Grievous is a lot dumber than the Brutes.

    In other words, he has to face GG on a level field without any outside help and with standard issue weapons. In other words, he only has UNSC weapons, which are inferior to the Covenant’s weapons which is pathetically weak compared to SW grade weaponry.

  • Zach
    January 15, 2010
    #16

    A shot through his eye socket would be an easy shot from say, 100 meters out. MC runs away and takes up a sniping post. Any close quarters stuff would end with John getting his head cut off.

  • MEGADOOMER
    January 26, 2010
    #17

    Once again, the two things I love most in the world clash. This fight could end with either one winning. The Chief’s shields could deflect a lightsaber, but once his shields are depleted, GG will cut through MC’s armor like 2 day old butter. However, MC could win 2 ways, first, seeing how Greivous’s armor is close to indestructable, he could shoot GG in the eye, that would kill him. Also, if Johnny boy could land a sticky grenade on Grievous, the explosion would not destroy his body, the radiation and area of effect blast would liquify his organs. That is all. :)

  • Megaraptor18
    January 26, 2010
    #18

    “Also, if Johnny boy could land a sticky grenade on Grievous”

    Plasma grenades are not standard issue to MC so he cannot use them.

    If you wish to continue on this site please go by and look at the FactPile Debating Rules

    http://www.factpile.com/factpile-debating-rules.htm

  • LeonSKennedy
    February 13, 2010
    #19

    haha, ok, i’m a serious MC fanboy, but even i know when the chips are down, MC would get sliced to pieces by grievous’ lightsabers.
    MC would not have access to plasma grenades, they’re not part of his standard equipment.
    so yep, star wars takes another win from the haloverse.

  • Juggernaut
    February 19, 2010
    #20

    Chief would win By using those plasma grenades

  • Juggernaut
    February 19, 2010
    #21

    What would he have

  • Juggernaut
    February 19, 2010
    #22

    What would he have cheif that is

  • Django
    March 12, 2010
    #23

    well if Master Chief gets plasma grenades then General Greivous should get something special to like droidekas or something…….

  • Belisaurius
    March 26, 2010
    #24

    Hmm…

    Grievous would win as he deflects the bullets with his lightsabers then knocks MC’s shields down with a single hit.

  • RAWRii
    March 27, 2010
    #25

    SPARTAN LASER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Darkbladex96
    March 27, 2010
    #26

    Greivous for the FP award on the grounds that chiefs weapons cannot harm him.

  • LKMS
    April 3, 2010
    #27

    It kind of depends. As strong GG’s armor is, he is just as vulnerable underneath it. Minus the lightsabers, its no competition.

    But WITH the sabers, its much more difficult. His reaction time is slightly better than MC’s, so instead of being able to dodge bullets, he can just catch them on the blades. However, as they are BULLETS and not LASERS, there would be no rebound. And also blaster fire seems to go more slowly than gunfire. You can’t really see bullets in flight, tracer rounds notwithstanding. Blasterfire you can see from a mile away. Full auto assault rifle to Grievous? Even Vader in his prime would have troubles with that. It all depends if MC gets a lucky shot to GG’s organs, or manages to stick a grenade to him. But things like the Spartan Laser would put GG out of the fight FAST

    Depends on luck.

  • W2drs21
    May 8, 2010
    #28

    Umm this is grievous at full health so his organs are not vurnerable.and grievous has better reflexes and is far faster than mc. Grievous defeated 6 Jedi at once in a battle and didn’t even get close to being defeated by them. Mc would get destroyed by 6 Jedi at once. Even one Jedi is enough to kill mc let alone grievous.

  • Darkbladex96
    May 8, 2010
    #29

    “Full auto assault rifle to Grievous? Even Vader in his prime would have troubles with that.”

    how little you know about jedi. Vader would have seen every shot coming a second before it happend would easily avoid them, stop them mid flight, or block them with his light saber. blasters actually fire lightspeed rounds, what you see is visual effects because no one wants to watch a movie where people point at people then they die. jedi react before the trigger is every pulled so it wouldnt matter what you shot at Vader with the outcome would be the same.

    Grievous’ reaction time is much higher then slightly better MCs it a different level. to outfight six precogs who can amp their speed and strength to the point that they can destroy droids with thier bare hands or move faster then the eye can see, is a feat above anything MC can counter.

  • Darkbladex96
    May 8, 2010
    #30

    and a spartan laser might not even dent grievous’ armor, it definitley wont kill him.

  • Omega-88
    May 17, 2010
    #31

    Umm this is grievous at full health so his organs are not vurnerable.and grievous has better reflexes and is far faster than mc. Grievous defeated 6 Jedi at once in a battle and didn’t even get close to being defeated by them. Mc would get destroyed by 6 Jedi at once. Even one Jedi is enough to kill mc let alone grievous.

    even a jedi padawan would kill mc.

  • W2drs21
    May 17, 2010
    #32

    Yup omega. I even think a standed clone trooper can take out mc.

  • JediRevan
    May 19, 2010
    #33

    “General Grievous was one of the most Succesfull Lightsaber combat jedi hunter in star wars history.”I agree with you W2drs21 and Omega-88.

  • w2drs21
    May 27, 2010
    #34

    Grievous for the Fact Pile award.

  • KB-Master Xion
    May 27, 2010
    #35

    Grievous’ comment on this match:
    I can do this with 2, no, 3 hands tied to my back.

    I always like it when he says that in Battlefront2

  • overlord
    June 25, 2010
    #36

    Chief all the way. . .

    You guys forget that he eliminated the flood and decimated high chairity. Can a lightsaber really block a splazer? Plasma? Or what about the big weakpoint at the center of his chest? Possibly a scarab gun?

  • Inarto
    June 25, 2010
    #37

    Maybe you should bother reading the rules before you post anymore?
    Standard equipment only so chief gets a battle rifle, smg or pistol and two frag grenades. Good luck even hitting him in the frist place, he can block all the shots, pull out two blasters and gun chief down.

  • ZomBninjasamurai
    June 25, 2010
    #38

    “You guys forget that he eliminated the flood and decimated high chairity. Can a lightsaber really block a splazer? Plasma? Or what about the big weakpoint at the center of his chest? Possibly a scarab gun?”

    what would a splazer or plasma hope to do to him?

  • ZomBninjasamurai
    June 25, 2010
    #39

    “Maybe you should bother reading the rules before you post anymore?
    Standard equipment only so chief gets a battle rifle, smg or pistol and two frag grenades. Good luck even hitting him in the frist place, he can block all the shots, pull out two blasters and gun chief down.”

    even if MC gets every weapon he can from Halo… Grevious will cut him down within ten seconds

  • Laharl
    June 25, 2010
    #40

    “even if MC gets every weapon he can from Halo… Grevious will cut him down within ten seconds”WITH TE RINGZ MASTERCHEF WOULD WINZ LOLOLOLOL!OLO!L!OL!O!L!LOLO

  • Darkbladex96
    June 25, 2010
    #41

    “You guys forget that he eliminated the flood and decimated high chairity. Can a lightsaber really block a splazer? Plasma? Or what about the big weakpoint at the center of his chest? Possibly a scarab gun?”

    6 jedi vs grevious equals 6 dead jedi….more of a feat then anything MC has done. Scarab gun is a easter egg weapon, MC doesnt have a splazor or plasma weapons…besides what would those weapons do when they are so far below blasters? since this is grevious at full, his armor has no weakpoints.

  • overlord
    June 26, 2010
    #42

    “Maybe you should bother reading the rules before you post anymore?
    Standard equipment only so chief gets a battle rifle, smg or pistol and two frag grenades. Good luck even hitting him in the frist place, he can block all the shots, pull out two blasters and gun chief down.”

    I have, and splazers are designed for spartans.

    “what would a splazer or plasma hope to do to him?”

    One cannot hope to block plasma as it is a gas and would hit regardless of the lightsaber in its way. splazer is too big to block.

  • Inarto
    June 26, 2010
    #43

    “I have, and splazers are designed for spartans.”
    But his standard loadout is the assault rifle, magnum/smg and two grenades so that is what he gets here

  • Inarto
    June 26, 2010
    #44

    “One cannot hope to block plasma as it is a gas and would hit regardless of the lightsaber in its way. splazer is too big to block.”
    Hardly. The Dc-15 fires bolts of palsma and its deflected fine by a lightsaber.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7A07WNupEXk
    at 1:04 he easilyy defelcts a laser cannon blast the splazer would be no differant.

  • midnite marauder
    June 26, 2010
    #45

    Stop feeding the troll.

  • Eric Gigliotti
    June 26, 2010
    #46

    Ummmm, MC gets his shit wrecked? Duh! How can MC kill Grevious? Grenades? Grevious will slice it in two. Assault Rifle or Magnum? The bullets will just bounce off of Grevious’ durasteel. Grevious’ lightsabers will receive *NO* resistance from MC’s armor and shields.

  • overlord
    June 26, 2010
    #47

    “But his standard loadout is the assault rifle, magnum/smg and two grenades so that is what he gets here”

    Good point.

    “Hardly. The Dc-15 fires bolts of palsma and its deflected fine by a lightsaber.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7A07WNupEXk
    at 1:04 he easilyy defelcts a laser cannon blast the splazer would be no differant.”

    Good evidence. It seems that I’m forced to submit. GG wins.

  • overlord
    June 26, 2010
    #48

    “Stop feeding the troll.”

    With what, words? I am no troll.

  • Soldier's Shadow
    July 10, 2010
    #49

    The sad thing is that this is probably Chief’s only chance of defeating a lightsaber wielder and he gets defeated easily still. I think this would still be a cool fight if it were to happen until Grievous cuts MC into fillets.

  • Neutrality
    July 19, 2010
    #50

    I hope MC fans like their MC sliced thinly, surrounded by rice and wrapped in seaweed!

    because really…what else will GG do with him?

Leave a Reply:



By submitting a comment here you grant this site a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. Please try to keep the language on the clean side - for the most part, you can say what you want and use an * instead of a key vowel, and we'll know what you meant to say. Thanks!


«   |   »
Categories
Heads Up Recent Posts Latest Comments Most Popular Topics Polls

Are you going to see Machete?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...