Here is a match that would be extremely entertaining to watch. While I am not as familiar with the Gundam universe as I am with Star Trek, I know they both can pack a punch.
Who wins this galactic showdown?
Here is a match that would be extremely entertaining to watch. While I am not as familiar with the Gundam universe as I am with Star Trek, I know they both can pack a punch.
Who wins this galactic showdown?
January 11, 2009
#1
Star Trek. While i think Gundam is badass, Star Trek “packs a bigger punch” because of the huge story line and all the tech and weapons.
January 11, 2009
#2
The gundam universe has this. I am going to assume all of the organizations from every series is united against the trekies.
I’ll step aside for the moment and see how star trek feel they can compete.
January 11, 2009
#3
Gundam would own Star Trek; they are more mobile, have more weapons and are generall more easy to control.
January 11, 2009
#4
Star Trek wins this. Gundam would have no chance in hell against the combined powers of the Borg, Dominion, Federation, Klingons, Roumlans, and the thousands of other advanced species in the Star Trek galaxy. On top of that, the tech of Star Trek completely surpasses Gundam’s tech and is much more devastating. The yield of a standard photon torpedo can reach into the hundreds of megatons.
I would love to see the Gundam suits try to outmaneuver a volley of photon torpedoes travelling at low warp speeds.
January 12, 2009
#5
I don’t watch Gundam. But could see one of those Gundam ships ripping apart a star trek vessel very easily with there hands.
January 12, 2009
#6
You guys wanna talk about packing a bigger punch? Wing zero, the most powerful of the mobile suits seen on Gundam Wing, the weapon that inspired terror in Oz and space colony foces, the beam cannon, was the very definition of devastation, entire battalions of mobile suits and mobile dolls, entire space colonies were destroyed by a single shot from this weapon, star trek ships Will Not hold up. The zero system, designed to continuasly analyze battle data and statistics and feed them back to the pilot, the psychological effects were the removal of fear and emotional prohibitions felt by the pilot, the battle becomes a strategy game, the pilot will not hesitate to use whatever weapons his suit is equipped with, in Wing Zero’s case the infamous rifle I spoke of. Gundanium alloy, all the gundam’s armor plating is made up of this material, near immutable, neutral electric charge, and an incredibly high melting point. It is extremely effective, most who did not know what gundanium was thought the gundams were invincible. A mobile suit pair known as the Vayeate and Mercurious were built by oz using gundanium, Vayeate took a hit from Wing Zero’s beam cannon and was about sixty percent intact. This was the same weapon that literally vaporizes standard mobile suits and blew a space colony to pieces of debris, Gundanium can take a beating.
Standard mobile suits and mobile dolls, Oz and space colony rebels have them to spare. While the Leo and Ares were primarily made for combat on earth, The leo would later be converted to space combat worthiness. But, however, Oz came up with two mobile suits, Taureus and Virgo, and gave them the mobile doll system. These were automated units capable of carrying out destruction of targets with more accuracy than most human pilots. The virgo was a larger, slower unit but carried a large beam cannon to compensate, though not as powerful as Wing Zero’s, virgos were dispatched in overwhelming numbers to terminate a target. Taurus mobile dolls were a lighter unit but didn’t quite have virgo level firepower, they could change form into a highly agile fighter form to quickly relocate when needed. At space fortress libra a modified doll control system was made combining it with a zero system, it was given an idividual named dorothy, one of the more influential members of the white fang. The system comprised of the system, a helmet worn by the user displaying the battle and allowed the user to control mobile doll forces by will alone. The last version of the Virgo were equip with electromagnetic shield generators created by three discs orbiting the unit, dorothy would have three virgos huddle and combine their shields and create a shielded firing platform capable of firing in any direction.
Space fortress Libra, Oz’s last hope for space supremacy, taken over by rebels lead by former Oz ace pilot Zechs Marquis. At the center of the sinister installation is a beam weapon that easily dwarfed the feared beam cannon of wing Zero, once fired upon earth, it caused destruction that looked like god’s wrath in magnitude, Judging by what I saw, most countries would be wiped clean.
Now I could easily go on and give more info on gundams from all the other series’, But I wanna know how star trek forces could go toe to toe with what I explained.
January 12, 2009
#7
Species 8472…virtually unbeatable. nuff said. And the borg could assimilate the gundams…that wouldnt be good for non-assimilated gundams…
January 12, 2009
#8
What about Q, the being with god-like powers?
January 13, 2009
#9
Yea there are many godlike species in the Star Trek universe.
How large are the factions in the Gundam universe? Do they spread across the galaxy?
January 13, 2009
#10
The Quantum would be enough to obliterate the entire Gundam universe and all of its denizens with a mere flick of the proverbial wrist. Q, having an affinity for the Federation, would probably annihilate every Gundam warrior for simply getting in his way of annoying Piccard.
Star Trek wins this one on an account of supremely powerful inter-galactic deities.
January 13, 2009
#11
Okay, I forgot about the quantum, Am I safe to assume that is the only trump card? At the time of my last post I was thinking tech vs tech. But me knowing the fact that the supernatural beats tech anytime, I might go with star trek if the quantum were involved in the fight, But in a war without them I would still say gundam. BTW the borg could not assimilate gundams, they need a pilot, they are not autonomous like transformers.
January 13, 2009
#12
“it caused destruction that looked like god’s wrath in magnitude, Judging by what I saw, most countries would be wiped clean.”
Thats it? A fleet made up of 20 Romulan and Cardassian ships destroyed 30 percent of a planet’s crust in just the openning volley.
The fact is, the Gundam universe just doesn’t have the numbers or tech to repel the amount of firepower Star Trek would bring in. The Borg alone could just swarm hundreds of thousands of cubes through Gundam space, assimilating everything they can. They even have the tech to travel back in time and try to assimilate or destroy Gundam’s Earth. Again, Star Trek has thousands of species with all types of incredible technology. With all that power and knowledge combined, Gundam is simply screwed.
January 13, 2009
#13
Only one trump card is needed when said trump card is capable of utterly and entirely obliterating all opposition with only a mere notion in their direction.
With Q’s almost “older brother” like affinity for the Federation and Star Trek denizens in general, I doubt that this fight would go on any longer than mere seconds if Gundam ever presented itself as a threat in any way shape or form.
January 14, 2009
#14
I tend as a rule to never justify the reasons behind the elements in Anime storylines. There are of course a few exceptions, but Gundam is really not one of them.
So parting from that rule of thumb, I will take the logical avenue and give this to the far richer universe of Star Trek.
January 14, 2009
#15
even admiral odama could PW3N gundum, Galactica i’m talking about.
the borg alone would be enough to assimulate anything. the klingons would be ripping apart the gundoms arms and whos that guy from nemisis. ahh pretore shinzon. with his awsome ship the predator. and also Captain James T. Kirk all he has to do is poke any gundom and the machine would just fall apart.
January 14, 2009
#16
Locutus:”Thats it? A fleet made up of 20 Romulan and Cardassian ships destroyed 30 percent of a planet’s crust in just the openning volley.”
You failed to see my point. In your post a fleet fired upon a planet. One unit, one space installation carried that much firepower, capable of putting thermonuclear weapons to shame, one unit compared to a fleet warships. and with the mobile doll force defending and epyon at the lead. heavy losses would surely be suffered by star trek fleets. I still acknowledge that the quantum would decimate the gundam universe I just wanted to demonstrate the already underestimated abilities of the gundam universe.
I mentioned A gundam known as epyon. I was too busy bragging on Wuing Zero to describe some of the others, Here is a web page describing it better than I can: “The Gundam Epyon. It is questionably the strongest of the Gundams built during the Wing series. It boasts an incredibly powerful generator system that directly feeds its beam sword, an strong heat rod, and features a second mode for flight that conserves energy use. Equipped with a variation of the Wing Zero’s cockpit system, it destroys all of the pilot’s fears to make him the ultimate warrior. The perfect weapon in every way but one, the Epyon has only one thing that could be called a flaw, it features no long range weapons.”
This unit’s beam saber hacked straight through a space fortress, destroying it. Among ships from star trek it would move with the utmost agility destroying it the same way it destroyed countless mobile suits and a space fortress
The most effective tool is as follows:The ZERO (Zoning & Emotional Range Omitted) System is a technology for interfacing the brain of the pilot with the mobile suit’s computer (comparable to the Universal Century’s biocomputer in the F91 Gundam). Only two known mobile suits were ever equipped with this system, the XXXG-00W0 Wing Gundam Zero and the OZ-13MS Gundam Epyon. The ZERO system decreases the pilot’s reaction times as there is no need for traditional visual interfaces. Furthermore, thanks to the advanced computations performed by the computer, the pilot can become aware of future outcomes and possible courses of action that can be taken to achieve total victory or total defeat. However, due to this direct brain interface, as the human brain cannot process the raw data, the system will cause the pilot to vividly “hallucinate” the possible paths that the pilot can take; as the pilot tries to figure out what is going on, the system can overload the brain with too many statistics and estimated values, causing temporary insanity. Examples of this include when Quatre Raberba Winner used the Wing Zero and went on a rampage throughout the colonies, and when Heero Yuy first used the Epyon in battle and went berserk, killing every soldier on both sides. However by the end of the series both Heero and Zechs “master” the ZERO system allowing them to properly use the data that the system gives them.
Later during the White Fang conflict, Gundam pilot Heero Yuy and White Fang leader Zechs Merquise developed a modified version of the ZERO system that was derived from their respective Gundams. They were given to Gundam pilot Quatre Raberba Winner and White Fang supporter Dorothy Catalonia so that they could lead their respective forces with their maximum potential strategic abilities. Heero installed his into Quatre’s XXXG-01SR Gundam Sandrock (which Quatre would later remove) and Zechs developed his into a helmet for Dorothy to use to control and coordinate the movements of mobile dolls in combat from inside the battleship Libra.
http://gundam.wikia.com/wiki/Zero_System
That said I truly am saddened that the quantum will most likely be involved, because otherwise the gundams would achieve supremacy. And I have read about the borg and it seems that assimilation is not as easy as some made it out to be, especially since some escape assimilation or successfully resist it. If Picard can do it I’m fairly sure some of the gundam pilots can.
January 14, 2009
#17
Saddened? Why do you take such a personal stance on everything to a degree that you’re practically offended by almost everyone and anything.
The Quantum exist whether we like it or not, and their removal would not only be consistent with poor form (“That’s too powerful, you can’t have it!”) in the midst of a debate; but would also be equivalent to stripping Link of his magical attire, denying the Halo array to the forerunners or saying that Darth Vader should not have the force simply because it gives him too much of an advantage. That’s not we work here and you know it.
Unless anyone can logically contest, I declare unto the admin that I nominate Star Trek on the basis of having a whole pantheon of actual Gods capable of annihilating, undoing, obliterating or even transforming any opposition with only a moment of thought, a blink of an eye, a flick of wrist, etc.
January 15, 2009
#18
Nomination noted, this could be one of the most lopsided victories so far…
January 15, 2009
#19
I think you don’t understand what my point is The One Sin. We are not just talking about a few powers in the Alpha or Delta Quadrents, we are talking about the combined strength of the entire Star Trek galaxy. Tell me, are there millions of these Gundams that can travel either at or faster than high warp/transwarp speeds and swarm through the Star Trek galaxy, overcoming the combined powers of countless advanced species? If not, then the damage caused by the Gundam galaxy would be probably be minimal at most before they were overwhelmed and crushed by the scientific and technological might of countless Star Trek species. I highly doubt it would need godlike beings to win this.
“And I have read about the borg and it seems that assimilation is not as easy as some made it out to be, especially since some escape assimilation or successfully resist it. If Picard can do it I’m fairly sure some of the gundam pilots can. ”
All it takes is one assimilated Gundam and its pilot for the Borg to possibly adapt and add the tech to their own power.
You also forgot about their ability to time travel.
January 15, 2009
#20
L-W:”Saddened? Why do you take such a personal stance on everything to a degree that you’re practically offended by almost everyone and anything.”
It’s not that, I just really had my hopes up that I could win this, but I was happy to to bring gundam info to the table because we rarely talk about gundam. I was really only sad that I forgot about the quantum and the own they would bring. I just can’t resist the opportunity to really talk about my favorite anime since childhood. Gundam is to me what Warhammer 40k is to you, thats all. And for the record I’m not offended by everyone and everything, you are the only person that has offended me by insulting my intelligence, but I still respect you and your knowledge on these topics so its cool I guess.
Locutus, Watch Gundam Wing, You will understand the power in the Gundam units.
So I guess I lost this one too, but hey, my time will come.
January 20, 2009
#21
So much for one-sided warfare…..I Like the Gundam 00 pic here…cool…I would like to comment on the one who requested this Universe war….Pls. try to make your request more profound, This thread is perfectly imbalance, I can also make a one-shot reason here for Stark Trek to win in a Grotesque manner How?….The Borg only needs to send a single space craft on Earth(Gundam Perspective) then assimilate all humans, poof….they are turned into toys….so, no one will be able to pilot a mobile suit….What will happen to the mobile suits? Simple, they will become monuments that will rust…..Gundam universe here is utterly lambasted without a single percentage of winning….
January 20, 2009
#22
I feel mortified on the Gundams here….they are absolutely look like upstarts and tiresome gnats in the eyes of the Q
January 22, 2009
#23
“I feel mortified on the Gundams here….they are absolutely look like upstarts and tiresome gnats in the eyes of the Q”
Gnats with big guns!
*giggidy*
January 22, 2009
#24
Yeah, Gnats! Gnnnaaaaattttssss!!!!!!
The technology of the Enterprise is a light year away from the gundams…..example: Light Speed Travel(Gundams don’t have this)
January 25, 2009
#25
Except for the devil Gundam which can bring dead soldiers back to life. It also has the power of self-evolution, Self -regeneration, and self-replication.
January 25, 2009
#26
‘The technology of the Enterprise is a light year away from the gundams…..example: Light Speed Travel(Gundams don’t have this)”
Maybe so, but it only takes one gundam to destroy the enterprise, it could use that light speed travel to get out.
January 27, 2009
#27
Yeah but do u think that by capturing a single Enterprise could put a chance for the gundams to vanquish the Qs and The Borgs…..Think Again
January 28, 2009
#28
Capture? I said one gundam could destroy the enterprise, not capture it. most the leaders in the gundam are too reckless and suicidal to worry about capturing enemy tech, just look at operation meteor and the self detonation devices.
January 28, 2009
#29
And I really do think that the borg would have the hassle of their lives assimilating gundams and their pilots, if Heero and Zechs can put up with the zero system what will the borg brainwashing do unless it has to do with cybernetics? and the gundam pilots are kinda like kamikaze pilots, some of them wouldn’t hesitate to self detonate and destroy everything around them causing the borg to miss out on another unit to assimilate.
January 29, 2009
#30
Ok, so destroy an Enterprise, pheewww…. that would be 100% impossible…..all the enterprise need to do is to warp away….gundams haven’t reach pluto…..star trek universe has travelled many galaxy without a sweat….self detonate? nyahahahaha!!!!! i could use a laugh on that. well if heero commits suicide by self detonating, do u think that would be enough to wipe out The Borg? Think AGAIN!!!!…they don’t need to assimilate gundam pilots, they could assilimate the humans on earth to use them as meat shields….so if there’s no human left in the earth, where would the gundam pilots take their supplies? they could die in hunger and their gundams will no longer be repaired and re-armed! another thing….The Qs….hmmm, my trump card…well i just wonder If the gundams can take a glance at the GODS of the Star Trek universe. If they see a Q they will be flayed million miles away in a blink of an eye and then imploding into pieces….just like what Horus did to a Custodian who stepped in the middle of the Duel of Horus & THE GOD EMPEROR OF MAN, HORUS just glanced at the Custodian then poof!….too bad gundam universe doesn’t have this kind of stuff…..like THE IMMORTAL GOD EMPEROR
January 30, 2009
#31
As Diana said, the Borg could just assimilate everything else. While the the Borg are swarming through Gundam space with thousands of cubes, they will have thousands of other species backing them up with fleets of ships numbering in the millions. Game over.
January 30, 2009
#32
Nobody has caught on yet, I realize that the gundam universe would lose but its not so cut and dry.
Operation meteor, colony rebels were going to drop a colony onto earth, killing two billion people and then the gundams would go to earth and gain dominance, Milliardo peacecraft(Zechs) attempted to drop part of libra on earth to the same effect in a last ditch effort. That being their frame of mind, they will sacrifice it all to do all the damage they can to all the targets they can, and having a cockpit system that will show you the most destructive way to kill yourself either doesn’t hurt either.
Have you ever heard of a scorched earth policy? It’s kind of the same idea.The gundam lose, but not without doing all they can to destroy all they can, including themselves to prevent assimilation.
I know the Q could beat them with a thought and flick of the wrist, but will they? Will they sit back and enjoy the show until they get bored or suddenly think that they should help?
Then again, I’ve been talking about the Gundam wing universe, not the other units from another series like the self evolving, self regenerating colony devil gundam.
But, of course, the quantum, instant win because that is just how over the top startrek is. I would like to see star trek vs wh40k, or gundam vs something not so grossly overpowered.
January 30, 2009
#33
I understand what you’re saying. I still don’t think the Gundams would cause that much damage. Maybe on the scale of the Gundam universe it would be a lot, but not on the Star Trek scale. You think powers such as the Klingons, Romulans, Dominion, etc wouldn’t do what it took to win?
The Q would probably just sit back and watch. They wouldn’t be needed to achieve a quick victory.
January 30, 2009
#34
Whats the use of scorched earth policy if u knw at first hand that all in the gundam universe will die? whats that? gundams wouldn’t give up without a fight? too pathetic
January 31, 2009
#35
too pathetic? And I suppose you simply assume a clean sweep for star trek, right? And who said all of the gundam universe’s units and people will die? I said that if push came to shove they wouldn’t hesitate. I have been talking about the Gundam wing universe so far, but if I must I can describe the major contenders of a series like Mobile Fighter G Gundam or the others, and their ultimate weapon, the final evolution of the devil gundam, a colony within itself. A unit capable of producing it’s own army, assimilating other units and people(sound familiar?), evolving, and regenerating. If a unit can create weapons, resurrect the dead, and built it’s own mobile suit army, what need is there to destroy every thing when you can create more when you wish. Units like the devil gundam, god gundam, Wing zero, Epyon, Gp02A, death army, Qubeley, The O, Quin mantha, heavenly kings, and all the rest. Star trek would have an awful time without the quantum, thats all there is to it.
February 3, 2009
#36
Even so, The Q will wipe them out…….inevitably
February 5, 2009
#37
Well, I really like Gundam and, in terms of which one is a more fun, engrossing sci-fi universe, it’s a tough call. In terms of winning a war, however, it’s ridiculously to even compare them. It’s like comparing cavemen to modern militaries or even a flintlock-armed force.
In Gundam they have to use rotation to generate gravity. That creates extreme problems in terms of manueverability. They don’t have faster-than-light travel so Star Trek forces can pop in, fire a few shots, pop back into warp. Which is actually their standard tactic from TOS. Plus weren’t energy shields like ‘OMG so scary and advanced!!!’ in Gundam?
Hell, the whole plot device of why the mobile dolls from Gundam Wing were so terrifying was because they could respond faster than humans and had shields. Um, just about everything but tricycles have those in Star Trek. (And the tricycles probably can fly)
Not to mention that Star Trek tech has inertial dampeners. They don’t have those in Gundam Wing. Even super soldiers like Heero Yuy would be paste at 50g. In Star Trek, they can shift speeds from 0 to several hundred times the speed of light in less than a minute. That’s millions of Gs. Each ‘warp factor’ is supposed to be the speed of light to the *power* of that number, not a multiple of that number.
And range and devastation of weapons? Even original series talked about laying waste to the surface of a planet inside an hour. That’s one ship. So, from a military standpoint, Gundam is outclassed by the average shuttle-craft. The only advantage is in the Zero system from Gundam Wing. Worthless unless you have massed numbers using it. Too bad it drives nearly everyone insane who uses it.
Also, with the numbers that just Starfleet can mass on it’s own? Just because the Zero system can predict the future doesn’t mean it can solve everything. Let’s just say that the Zero system can predict everything, and can predict it at faster than the speed of light. Okay, let’s say you have a bunch of pilots who can impossibly all use the future-reading system. It’s still useless. Because of the speed involved with Star Trek technology you would need (for all practical purposes) an infinite number of super-soldiers, in Gundams, all with the Zero system to match the crappiest warp-capable Star Trek ship. They just can’t move fast enough.
Star Trek vessels also are used to targeting ships travel at near and faster than light speeds. And scorched earth, as a military strategy, is terrible if you only have one port of call (and I’m counting the whole solar system as a port of call). So, that’s out. So, as much as I like Gundam, in all reality, a half dozen long-range passenger shuttles are more than a match for everything the Gundam universe can throw down. You can’t kill what you can’t catch (they can just run away even if they have no weapon systems at all.)
Gundam universe is just too far behind technologically. No FTL, no control over inertia, no chance. Any other concern is pointless. There’s not even any need for Q, other worlds, other races or even a fleet. A single warp-capable starship from TOS wins inside a day because there is no practical way for Gundams to hurt it.
And to add insult to injury ST firepower is just irresistible to non-FTL technology. ST ships can dodge all day long and hit Gundams at will. That’s why they have the Prime Directive, exposure to their technology is enough to completely change a planet’s technological landscape, advancing it by hundreds or thousands of years (depending on how primitive it is). I mean, Gundam uses chemical propellants in some of the guns (in a number of the series). They still use hand-guns.
I mean, you’re kidding me, right?
February 6, 2009
#38
CEP, are you ok?……
February 6, 2009
#39
umm what would be the point of a flying tricycle (lol)
I just thought that was funny.
February 6, 2009
#40
No, I’m fine, I was just struck by the silliness of comparing two so very different universes. The tricycle thing was supposed to just show how goofy ST’s level of tech can be, sometimes. So much of it is at the *far* end of fiction in terms of science-fiction. Gundam (for all that giant fighting robots would have trouble standing) is rooted in harder science. In Star Trek you have time travel, teleportation (transporter), recreation of people/places/events (holodeck) and have cross-species children (not to mention taking a baby from one species and sticking it in the womb of another, thanks for that DS9). They only thing they haven’t managed yet is ‘M-preg’ and thank God for that, I would *not* want to see Patrick Stewart being thrown a baby shower. (If you want to get weird, I guess you could say Data counts since he built a daughter named Lal for himself)
Sometimes, Diana, when I type people think I’m getting mad, but I’m really just getting hyperactive.
February 7, 2009
#41
Would you like to drink some water or coffee? Or would you like to take some psychotropics to be calmed? Or would you like me to take you to an asylum?
March 11, 2009
#42
i love gundam but st would win by numbers alone
September 9, 2009
#43
Turn A and Turn X using moonlight butterfly at 100%.
March 13, 2010
#44
considering warp drive the only way for the gundams to defeat startrek is if they have warp drive installed on them otherwise i think it will be a one sided battle, and I love gundams but the Gundam Infinity justice or Legend ZGMF X666 have the best chance of destrying the enterprise since if he manage to surprise the enterprise even the shields of the enterprise will be useless….but only if they can ambush enterprise and Q no one can defeat him but i think he wont destroy the gundams(thats the fun in that) in fact he might even help them just to make the fight a bit more interesting like placing warp drives in Gundams
March 13, 2010
#45
He still wont kill picard
he might just let the warp drive equipped gundam to pound the enterprise just enough to annoy picard