i know there will be challenge but starkiller wins this by long not that easy but starkiller is the most powerful force user

Wow, my dream has been realized! Oh man this is tough… well, we know if it was close combat, mace would have the advantage. If its Force, Galen does, But Galen is very good at saber combat. So i have to give the slight edge to him, because is great at force, and good at saber, whereas Mave is Great at saber, and okay at force.

Still could definentally go either way.

Well, I don’t appreciate use of terms such as “retarded” they’re crude and have no place here. And to X on, next time you call someone an idiot, try to spell it correctly.

mace windo would win.

mace uses the saber form Vappid wich uses his own anger and the anger of your foe to boost your own power. and starkiller is one pissed of dude, mace would gain a huge advantige.

and mace has the shaterpoint skill. this is a rare force skill that alows the user to “see” and oppenents weekness.

power dosnt beat skill and mace is the most skilled jedi in the order.

“does it really matter if he spelled it correctly or not? your not a spelling elitist are you? even i could prove your ’simple equation’ wrong, with one of my own.”

I’m clearly pointing out the irony of misspelling the simple word “idiot” when referring to someone as such.

@helatus starkiller isn`t the most powerful force user ever sion, nihilus, kreia, darth revan and jedi exile any of them could wipe the floor with him and i don`t know who would win out of mace vs starkiller i think it depend how it play out just like the end of the force unleashed where you could either end up beating the emperor or getting killed really easy by him i think it would play out like that

exactly they`ll say anything that get them money

Im not so sure BF….Anyway, Galen marek should win.

fine i guess it is but lucasart just got greedy but i`ll go with starkiller cause he got a game made about him :p and i got another idea for duel the guy from fable 1 vs the guy from fable 2

let me just say this no one could defeat mace easily but im going to have to go with the apprentice (is what i call him none of this galen and starkiller BS) they both beat the emperor but of course that little bitch anakin had to come in and cut his damn arm off and with the apprentice gay ass kota had to say its not the jedi way so he didnt kill the emperor but good fight

Frist off I am glad that you used starkillers real name props to you admin!!!
This time I am glad to say Sith wins.
Mace (though he is a master jedi) whould stand no chance when faced with the fury of the Starkiller. Come on guys lets face it the starkiller was trained by the “One” so that alone is a winning factor but take in to account that he has such great force power that he could crush mace before mace could even turn on the lightsaber ( come on he could control a stardestroyer with the force)

P.s FUN FACT THE LIGHT SABER IS REALLY SOUND THE LIGHT COMES FROM THE CRISTAL INSIDE!!!

Starkiller because if he was distracted like in Episode 3, Starkiller could kill him.

I have to agree with Skrunks as far as it being a matter of opinion, but lets look at it all again shall we?

First off, although Galen Marek is the new badass hero in a new Starwars game that doesn’t mean he is the greatest, and unfortunately most people are basing their opinions on how much they kicked ass with him in the game.

Now i have both read the novel and played the game. i read the novel first because there is much more plot then in the game. The novel gets into the characters much more than the game does. not to mention the game rushes a lot of things. personally i feel that the game should have never have been made.

in the book Galen is a very powerful force user, and his abilities with a blade are very good as well, but he has only ever seen the dark side of the force until the end when he turns to the light. He hasn’t had a chance to experience all of the benefits of the lightside. There are many techniques on the lightside of the force that would allow marek to easily get the upper hand on anyone he fought when combined with his darkside knowledge.

Mace is a lightsider that had to look get very close to the darkside in order to use vappad. and if you do research on the topic, it was such a dangerous and deadly lightsaber form that anyone who wanted to learn it had to get permission from mace himself to use it. also mace has a love for fighting. something everyone will discover with some research into his character. the reason why he is such a good fighter is because he fights like a sith. cold and cruel and the only outcome he sees from a fight is the death of his enemy. which is why he created vappad because it takes all those dark thoughts that he has and uses them to his advantage while fighting by channeling that power into his form.

now that we have went over what both of their basic stats are lets look at the fight.

Marek uses a defensive stance while fighting which may help him in the fight against Mace’s offensive style of fighting.
Mace however uses so much force in his fighting that it may cause Marek to become tired after repeated attack. This can also be very bad for Mace because he may get tired as well.

Marek is very strong in the force but as i have mentioned before he hasn’t harnessed all the powers from both sides of the force to make him stronger, while Mace Has with his form of fighting.

Not to mention that the only way mace and Marek would fight would be if Marek didn’t turn to the lightside thus never gaining the knowledge of lightside powers therefor mace would defeat Marek due to Marek’s lack of knowledge in the force.

And as i have said before the only reason why some of the people on here are saying marek would win is because they kicked ass with him in a video game.

I apologize if i have offended anyone but i felt the need to get my mind across.

Id say Galen, massive command of the force and an unpredictable fighter.

I’ve had it with these muthafukin siths, on this muthafukin plane!

I’ve always taken Lucas’s statement as Marek having the highest natural ability in the series, whereas others simply have access more powerful techniques, such as the Force Storm Wormhole and Nihilus’s life drain, or have had more experience.