No research needed here. Easily a battle of the ages. Take into consideration the captains of each ship and the advantage would go to the Enterprise. But for sheer firepower the Super Dimensional Fortress would make toast of the “Class of Starfleet” in about 12 seconds.
Enterprise
- Phasers
- Photon Torpedos
- Deflector shields
- Impulse engines
- Warp Drive
Super Dimensional Fortress (SDF-1)
- Super Dimension Energy cannon
- 4 1780 mm rail cannons
- 8 Beam Cannons
- Space-fold Drive
- Omni-directional barrier
My money is on the SDF-1 – any way the Enterprise survives?
Loading ...
July 10, 2008
#1
Enterprise hands down, all they’d have to do is beam a matter/antimatter bomb or nuclear device aboard and that’s that.
It would just be a matter of them getting within transporter range.
July 10, 2008
#2
If TNG StarTrek transporters don’t work against Borg shields, how’s TOS startrek transporters going to work against Macross’ Omni-directional barrier?
I don’t think any ships in the startrek universe would be able to withstand a hit from the Super Dimension Energy cannon.
Or Macross could just turn in to its giant robot form, and just punch the enterprise.
July 11, 2008
#3
I believe it depends greatly upon who the captain is of the Enterprise at the time of the fight.
Winner: Enterprise ::ENGAGE::
July 11, 2008
#4
Okay, if the captain of the Enterprise was Chuck Norris, or Goku, then yes, they’d win, but if it was any of the actual StarTrek captains, then there’s nothing they could do against the overwhelming firepower of Macross.
July 18, 2008
#5
Hey, I love both ST and RT, but lets put things in perpective:
Length of SDF-1: 1210 meters
Length of Enterprise: 289 meters
Crew of SDF-1: 20,000 military, 58,000 civilian
Crew of Enterprise: 430
You’ve got to realize that the SDF-1 could step on enterprise and not realize it. The pictures at the top of the page don’t do the scale difference justice. Kirk didn’t beat V-ger in a fight, he talked it out of destroying the Earth. In a straight fight, SDF-1 is going to win hands down. And if you do overload its omnidirectional barrier, you’re toast because it will explode with enough force to level the surface of a planet out to a radius of 20 miles, yet leave the SDF-1 undamaged.
July 29, 2008
#6
SDF shadows enterprise too much…. SDF wins
August 7, 2008
#7
how about the whole halo fleet (convenant and humans) vs. The whole star wars fleet (droids and others…)
interesting…admin (pontifixx)
August 15, 2008
#8
how bout the pilliar of autumn vs deathstar or halibred
September 22, 2008
#9
the sdf-1 wins easely, heck even one single VF-1S strike valkyrie can take doen the enterprise with reflex weaponry. Now if you want even more destructive power they can use macross frontier’s VF-171EX with “dimension eater” warheads wich basicvally rip apart space & time.
September 23, 2008
#10
Here ya go this should settle it.
This Picture IS TO SCALE>
http://i231.photobucket.com/albums/ee264/wolfoftheblackmoon/SHIPCOMP-1.jpg
September 24, 2008
#11
Has anybody considered veritechs/variable fighters in this??
September 24, 2008
#12
@jt – No one yet, but feel free to do so! Admin
January 28, 2009
#13
The SDF-1 without a doubt. If I was Kirk, I would piss off the citizen of Macross City.
January 28, 2009
#14
Ooops – I mean I WOULD NOT piss off the SDF-1.
January 31, 2009
#15
somebody make a metal gear vs ramdom pther mecha one on topic: sdf-1 will own
July 27, 2009
#16
Let’s disregard the fact that the SDF out classes the enterprise. Let’s also disregard the fact that the hull material can survive an uncontroled reentry and supersonic impact. Let’s also disregard the fact that the anti-ship cannons are as big as the enterprise and the omni-directional barrier aswell.
Let’s also disregard the veritechs, which would launch wave after wave of anti-ship missiles and the effective velocity of the fold system. Let’s also disregard the daedelus maneuver, which would be entirely pointless on a ship of the enterprise’s size anyway.
Let’s focus on the singular issue of how the hell is the enterprise going to survive a single attack from the reflex cannon.