Suggested by JMT
On the surface, this looks to be an entertaining match.
Both QB’s have good feet, and arms. Both can make things happen when the scripted play breaks down.
While Cam has certainly made an impact, my question is, how many Super Bowl rings does he have compared to Ben?
‘Nuff said.





















Are they fighting to the death?
-
If so I’ll have to go with Roethlisberger, the man is like a living tank.
-
I’m a Patriots fan, but those Steelers are hard rivals
Yeah, I’m gonna go with the guy who has a few Super Bowl rings over the guy who lead his team to a 6-10 regular season.
Yeah, I’m going for the black guy over the Rapist
I have not posted on the pile in almost 3 months but I will come out of my long hibernation just to say this: Ben stomps… So hard. The only way teams beat the steelers is because Ben loves getting tackled. It gives him a sexual rush. That’s the conclusion I came to last year when they lost to the Broncos
Allow me to clarify: This match is being judged by the same criteria as the Tom Brady-Aaron Rodgers match, shown here:www.factpile.com/7019-aaron-rodgers-vs-tom-brady/
That being said, Cam gets my vote in scenarios 1, 2, 3 and 5. Roethlisberger, on the other hand, has proven himself in scenario 4 before, while Cam has not.
Also, Admin? Mind changing the match header to reflect it was me who suggested this match?
Cam Newton is Tim Tebow in reverse: black, great stats (mostly… too many TOs), few wins. I’m going with the overhated-but-still-good Ben. At least he’ll still be called “Big Ben” in a few years… f*cking England…
Cam newton is the better QB and I have no doubts about that. The Panthers beyond a shadow of a doubt have the worst offensive line in the league an cam still manages to get 6 wins. For those of you who are just spouting off and don’t anything about football the offensive line typically determines how good an offense is. That’s football 101 and anyone who says otherwise is just trying to sell tickets or they’re a moron. Cam still manages to through over 400 in several games, he’s a monster. Oh and he’s a far better runner than Ben, anybody who says otherwise is obviously high as Georgia pine.
-
Also Cam is a far harder worker than Ben because he wants it more. Any guy who gos racing around on a motorcycle obviously doesn’t give a good shit about his team.
-
Oh and one more thing, offense doesn’t win championships, defense does. The offense sales tickets ,so it’s irrelevant how many rings Ben has.
Big Ben got a rape charge and almost killed himself in a motorcycle accident but he didn’t get cut. Yet they send Vick to jail for two years over dog fighting and now Chad Johnson gets cut over a headbutt and we’re not even sure if he headbutted her. That’s some bullshit but any way the jets need a receiver and tebow needs some to pray with